v0
306 Commits
| Author | SHA1 | Message | Date | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Colin McDonnell
|
dc4dff98da |
allowlist middleapi/orpc for OSS, ship skill scaffold + no-mock audit
- utils/ossRepos.ts: add middleapi/orpc (orpc.dev, 5.2k stars) to the oss allowlist so any future install mints via mintOssKey ($10 cap, pullfrog absorbs). - scripts/skill.ts + pnpm skill: scaffold .agents/skills/<name>/SKILL.md + .claude/skills/<name> symlink. patch + skill skills written using it. - AGENTS.md: hard-ban vi.* mocking apis; document pnpm skill workflow. - audit follow-through: drop pure-mock test files (action/utils/lifecycle, action/utils/timer, test/handleNoInstall) and trim action/mcp/review to the non-mock cases. - wiki/scripts.md: row for scripts/skill.ts. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
a0746dcc27 | release: bump action to 0.1.13 | ||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
01e4daa0b5 |
checkout_pr: refuse unconditionally on dirty working tree (#808)
* checkout_pr: refuse unconditionally on dirty working tree drop the live-HEAD comparison from the guard introduced in #796. any checkout_pr call with staged or unstaged changes now throws, even when HEAD is already on pr-N. no stashing, no idempotent escape hatch. motivation is the zed-industries/cloud (2026-05-18) incident: shared-cwd subagents make "carry edits along" semantics dangerous, and the HEAD-equality predicate let a re-checkout silently inherit working-tree state from a sibling agent. forcing commit/discard before any PR-context operation eliminates the entire carry-forward failure class. error names the PR number, lists dirty paths, and tells the agent to commit/push/restore/clean before retrying. * improve dirty-tree error: precise discard commands copilot caught two sloppy bits in the error string: - "push" alone does not clean a dirty tree (needs commit first) - bare `git clean` is a no-op without `-fd` reword to "commit (then push if needed), or discard with `git restore --staged --worktree .` / `git clean -fd`" so the guidance is actually actionable. * checkout_pr: initial-branch invariant setupGit captures `toolState.initialBranch` at run start via live `git rev-parse --abbrev-ref HEAD`. checkout_pr refuses unless current HEAD matches the run-entry branch or the target `pr-N` (idempotent same-PR re-checkout). uses live rev-parse, not toolState.issueNumber (poisonable per the PR #796 review). refusal error names the current branch, target PR, recovery path (`git checkout <initialBranch>` with the literal branch name), and explicitly states routing around via the `git` tool is not sanctioned. closes the zed-industries/cloud (2026-05-18) shape where a subagent parked HEAD on someone else's `pr-X` and the orchestrator's next checkout_pr inherited that position. * reviewfrog: enforce canonical diff + pre-commit halt; align Build dispatch extend REVIEWER_SYSTEM_PROMPT with two prepended HARD CONSTRAINTS: - first action MUST be `git diff origin/<base>` (single-rev, captures uncommitted). no other diff first; no checkout_pr; no alt-ref fetches; no branch listing; no `gh pr list`. - empty canonical diff + claimed-changes dispatch ⇒ reply exactly with `no changes detected — likely pre-commit Build self-review; orchestrator should commit then re-dispatch` and stop. do not guess PR numbers (the zed thrash that ended in `checkout_pr({2582})`). reshape Build mode reviewfrog dispatch step around a verbatim template that names: (a) the situation is pre-commit, (b) canonical diff command, (c) halt-on-empty-diff rule. orchestrator side now says the same thing as the reviewer's baked-in prompt. delegation-discipline bullets and orchestrator-evaluation guidance kept intact. * checkout_pr: handle detached-HEAD entry in initial-branch invariant pullfrog incremental review caught a defense-in-depth gap: `git rev-parse --abbrev-ref HEAD` returns the sentinel string `"HEAD"` on detached entry, which is the default `actions/checkout` state for `pull_request` events. with the previous string-typed `initialBranch`, both the captured value and the live probe would equal `"HEAD"` on any detached state, trivially satisfying the invariant — including a subagent doing `git checkout --detach <sha>`. discriminate the captured HEAD: probe `git symbolic-ref --short HEAD` first (works on named branches), fall back to `git rev-parse HEAD` (SHA) on detached entry. store as `{ kind: "branch"; name } | { kind: "detached"; sha }`. checkout_pr runs the identical probe at call time and compares like-with-like (branch name vs branch name, SHA vs SHA). refusal error renders both heads via a small `describeHead` helper and chooses the right `git checkout` recovery target (branch name or SHA). no inline-discriminant `as` casts — uses a top-level `headsEqual` that narrows via the discriminator. |
||
|
David Blass
|
d3b5340583 |
fix: audit batch — MCP timeouts, entryPost, vip_audit 404s, and 6 more (#824)
* fix: 9 unaddressed log-audit / run-audit findings Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> #815 entryPost stdlib-only imports; #823 MCP timeoutMs on checkout_pr/shell; #816 FREE_FALLBACK → opencode/big-pickle; #822 chunk GraphQL nodes ≤100; #817/#821 vip_audit 404 skip paths; #813 longer serializable retries; #818 run-context handler-entered log; #805 audit severity template. * fix: update footer test for big-pickle fallback slug Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * fix: anneal round 1 — ghaCore getState casing, post-hook timeout Match @actions/core STATE_ key semantics (no uppercasing), cap postApiFetch at 30s, trim serializable retries to stay under GitHub's 10s webhook window, log Clerk failures in getUserTokenByGithubLogin. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * revert: drop run-context handler log (#818 deferred) The #692 client-side fix is already on main; residual SyntaxError hits are old action pins. Per-request log added noise without fixing anything. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * document per-issue Closes syntax for audit PRs GitHub only auto-closes the first issue when numbers are comma-separated; /audits and AGENTS.md now require Closes before each issue number. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * fix: anneal round 2 — outreach privacy, alert resilience, vertex cleanup Filter private repos from VIP authority output, harden console alert lines against DB failures, drop spoofable changesets body check, and unset GOOGLE_APPLICATION_CREDENTIALS after vertex credential cleanup. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * refactor: drop codexHome re-export of detectCodexRefresh Import detectCodexRefresh directly from codexRefreshDetect.ts everywhere; rename the unit test file to match. codexHome.ts stays install-only. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * fix: drop deprecated minimax-m2.5-free; add paid minimax-m2.5 Remove the deprecated free MiniMax promo from the catalog, docs, and tests. BYOK fallback and picker copy stay on opencode/big-pickle. Add opencode/minimax-m2.5 and openrouter/minimax-m2.5 for Zen BYOK and Router. Pin #816 regressions with freeFallbackCatalog and runErrorRenderer unit tests. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * fix: hidden minimax-m2.5-free fallback for stored slugs Re-add opencode/minimax-m2.5-free as a hidden fallback alias to big-pickle so repos with the legacy slug still resolve as free. Drop live Zen API experiment tests in freeFallbackCatalog.test.ts. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
6c166ac1cc |
fix: prevent cross-PR push from subagent-induced branch switch (#796)
* fix: prevent cross-PR push from subagent-induced branch switch A workflow_dispatch run for zed-industries/cloud (workflow run 26036155393) force-pushed the orchestrator's work onto an unrelated engineer's PR branch (origin/reactivate-pro-plan, PR #2582). The orchestrator's reviewfrog subagent called checkout_pr({pull_number: 2582}), which (1) moved the shared working tree to pr-2582 and (2) persisted pushDest pointing at reactivate-pro-plan. The orchestrator's subsequent commit + push_branch then clobbered the victim PR. Recovery + disclosure in PR #2584. Three compounding bugs closed here: 1. checkout_pr dirty-tree guard had a first-call hole: the previous condition required ctx.toolState.issueNumber to already be set, so on workflow_dispatch runs the first checkout_pr (commonly from a subagent) bypassed the guard entirely. Now any PR switch with a dirty tree is refused, including the first switch of a run. Idempotent same-PR re-checkouts are still absorbed by alreadyOnBranch inside checkoutPrBranch. 2. push_branch trusted sticky pushDest blindly. Added a backstop: refuse pushes where the local branch matches /^pr-(\d+)$/ AND pushDest.remoteBranch differs from it AND the current run is not scoped to PR N (event.is_pr === true && event.issue_number === N). This catches subagent-induced silent branch switches even if a future bug reintroduces a first-call hole in fix #1. 3. Build-mode self-review prompt told the orchestrator to ship "the output of git diff" to the reviewer. The model in this run synthesized git diff main...HEAD, which excludes uncommitted work — and Build self-review runs BEFORE the commit, so the reviewer saw an empty diff and thrashed, eventually calling checkout_pr on a random PR to find something to look at. Prompt now specifies git diff origin/<base-branch> (two-dot, no HEAD), which compares the working tree against the remote base. Refs: zed-industries/cloud workflow run 26036155393 zed-industries/cloud#2582 (victim) zed-industries/cloud#2584 (disclosure) * review: key dirty-tree guard on current branch + drop 'two-dot' misnomer Address review feedback on PR #796. 1. checkout_pr dirty-tree guard now keys off the live current branch (git rev-parse --abbrev-ref HEAD), not ctx.toolState.issueNumber. issueNumber is ALSO set by get_issue / get_issue_comments / get_issue_events, so a subagent doing get_issue(N) followed by checkout_pr(N) on a dirty tree would have bypassed the original guard (issueNumber === pull_number). The current branch is the actual primitive for "would this call move HEAD" — querying it directly avoids correlating on toolState that other tools write to. 2. modes.ts: drop the wrong "two-dot" label on git diff origin/<base>. That's the single-rev form, not two-dot. Copilot was right that the label was confusing/contradictory with the actually-shown command. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
cb0dbcd371 |
feat(action): make prepush hook non-blocking after one failure (#777)
* feat(action): make prepush hook non-blocking after one failure push_branch now treats the repository's prepush hook as best-effort: it runs at most once per run, surfaces the failure output if the script exits non-zero, and every subsequent push_branch call this run skips the hook so the agent isn't blocked by failures unrelated to its change. The agent can iterate by running the hook command itself via the shell tool when shell access is available; push_branch will not re-run the hook automatically after a failure. Why: a one-line OSS-allowlist change took 9 minutes (#776) because the agent retried push_branch six times against a prepush hook that was failing for env-leak and missing-build-artifact reasons unrelated to the change. CI catches the same checks on the GitHub side; the local prepush gate was duplicating work and blocking unrelated fixes. - ToolState: new prepushFailureCount counter (per-run, never resets) - executeLifecycleHook: returns structured failure (kind/output/exitCode) so prepush can compose its own agent-facing message instead of inheriting the generic retry/no-retry advice meant for setup - push_branch: composes a shell-mode-aware error message; surfaces prepushSkipped on the success payload + appends a note to the message - instructions.ts + wiki/prompt.md + docs/comparisons.mdx: updated to reflect best-effort semantics * fix(action): clarify prepush latch semantics + soften static guidance review fixes from PR #777: - toolState comment, instructions, success message, tool description: replace "runs at most once per run" / "first call only" wording with the actual semantic — successful prepush keeps running on later push_branch calls; only a hook FAILURE latches the bypass. - tool description: drop hardcoded "via the shell tool" guidance so the static description doesn't mislead in shell:disabled runs (the dynamic agent prompt in instructions.ts already does shell-conditional messaging). - LifecycleHookFailure.output JSDoc: match the implementation (stderr-preferred fallback to stdout, empty for timeout/spawn). * fix(action): shorten prepush-skip log to terse operator telemetry the previous log line tried to address the agent ("re-run the hook command yourself via shell"), but log.info writes to the action runtime's stdout — the agent never sees it. agent-facing skip guidance already lives in the error message from buildPrepushFailureMessage, the success message when bypassed, and the system prompt in instructions.ts. log line is now just operator telemetry. * refactor(action): drop slop from prepush soft-fail self-audit pass after the previous review-fix round. removed duplication between code-level comment and the five other places that already explain the same behavior, tightened verbose JSDoc, and collapsed redundant clauses in agent-facing strings. - LifecycleHookFailure → discriminated union. drops the optional exitCode/spawnError fields (and the empty-output sentinel for timeout/spawn) plus the corresponding ?? fallbacks in the helper. - PushBranchTool: 7-line code comment above the latch removed (toolState field comment + tool description + error message + success message + system prompt all already cover it). tool description third sentence dropped (restated the second). success message tightened to a parenthetical. - buildPrepushFailureMessage: 4-line JSDoc → 1 line. shared "if you think the failure could indicate a real bug in your code" prefix factored out across the shell-conditional branches. - ToolState.prepushFailureCount comment: 8 lines → 3. the "what" is in git.ts; comment now only documents the invariant (never decremented within a run). - instructions.ts prepush guidance: collapsed nested bullets + ternary into one paragraph; dropped the "so re-running via shell is the only way…" tail that restated "push_branch will NOT re-run it". * fix(action): hint prepush bypass on dirty tree after hook failure When push_branch blocks on a dirty working tree and the prepush latch is already set, tell the agent the hook will be skipped once the tree is clean. * fix(test): narrow CI matrix for lifecycle and toolState changes Remove lifecycle.ts from ALWAYS_RUN_ALL and add lifecycle.ts + toolState.ts to push/git agnostic test coverage so PRs touching prepush latch logic run targeted tests instead of the full matrix. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
7e90e5cae6 |
Align Plan-mode prompts on report_progress as the canonical plan tool (#786)
* fix: align Plan-mode prompts on report_progress as the canonical plan tool Fixes #673. Three sites disagreed on where Plan output should be posted, letting a model synthesize a broken third interpretation (initial post via `report_progress({ target_plan_comment: true })`, which then misses the `existingPlanCommentId` precondition). This PR aligns all three on `report_progress` as canonical, with `target_plan_comment` reserved for revisions only: - `action/modes.ts` Plan step 4 — spell out that the initial plan post uses `report_progress` WITHOUT `target_plan_comment`, and that revisions go through `select_mode`'s PlanEdit override. - `action/mcp/comment.ts` `target_plan_comment` flag description — make the "revisions only" precondition explicit and call out the initial-post path by name. - `action/utils/instructions.ts` Progress reporting paragraph — drop the misleading "(e.g., Plan comments)" parenthetical that read as "use create_issue_comment for plans". `PlanEdit` (in `action/mcp/selectMode.ts`) was already correct and is unchanged. Intentionally out of scope (to keep the fix minimal): a `publish_plan` tool, removing the vestigial `create_issue_comment({ type: "Plan" })` branch, hardening the run-end cleanup guard for the `target_plan_comment but no existingPlanCommentId` fallthrough, and renaming `target_plan_comment`. * align create_issue_comment description with report_progress as canonical plan tool |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
f3d18401ac |
eager signup credit + free-OpenCode fallback when BYOK has no key (#789)
* eager signup credit + free-OpenCode fallback when BYOK has no key
addresses the silent-churn pattern that took out 15 first-run-failure
accounts post-launch: GH Actions secret references resolved to empty
strings (because the secrets didn't exist on the repo), the action
launched Claude Code with no key, the LLM provider 401'd, and the run
died in seconds with a synthetic "Invalid API key" message. those
accounts had no Router credits to fall back to because the lazy claim
required a dashboard visit they never made.
three changes, one PR:
1. Eager $10 signup credit at account creation. Both account-creation
sites (`upsertAccountByClerkId` for dashboard signin, `fetchOrCreateRepo`
for CLI / GH-App-only) now insert the `CreditGrant { reason: "signup" }`
in the same transaction as the `accounts` row. CLI installers who
never sign in get the credit. The dashboard `/signup-credit/claim`
POST stays as an idempotent backstop for accounts created before
this shipped.
2. Free-OpenCode fallback in the action. When the configured BYOK slug
needs a provider key the runner doesn't have, swap to
`opencode/minimax-m2.5-free` before agent selection so the run still
succeeds. Surfaced via a `» fell back from <slug> to <free>` warning
in the action log. Skipped on Router runs (Pullfrog mints the key)
and when no model is configured (auto-select-with-throw still fires
for the genuinely-misconfigured case).
3. New action-test fixture `byok-no-keys-fallback` that empty-strings
every known provider key (matching how GH Actions handles missing
secrets) and asserts the run succeeds with the fallback log line
present. plus a unit test for the helper covering each skip case.
skipping the schema flip from `byok` to `router` — that's coming via
the onboarding-stepper PR (#762).
* fallback: skip Bedrock + surface in PR-comment footer
addresses copilot review on #789 (real bug — parseModel throws on
Bedrock raw IDs that have no slash, would crash before
validateBedrockSetup could surface its own error) and the user-side
ask to make the fallback visible in PR comments.
- selectFallbackModelIfNeeded skips when resolvedModel has no '/' so
Bedrock routing IDs (e.g. us.anthropic.claude-opus-4-7) don't crash
inside hasProviderKey -> parseModel. unit test covers it.
- toolState.modelFallback records the configured slug we fell back
from. set in main.ts when fallback engages.
- buildPullfrogFooter accepts fallbackFrom and renders
"Using `MiniMax M2.5` (free) (credentials for Claude Opus not
configured)" so the substitution is visible in PR comments,
reviews, PR bodies, and error reports.
- threaded through all four action-side footer call sites
(mcp/comment, mcp/pr, mcp/review, utils/errorReport). server-side
call sites in triggerWorkflow.ts / handleWorkflowRunWebhook.ts
fire pre-action and don't have toolState — left as-is.
* fallback footer: use provider display name + document email asymmetry
addresses pullfrog reviewer findings on #789:
- footer now shows 'credentials for Anthropic not configured' (provider
display name from `providers.anthropic.displayName`) instead of the
per-model name. credentials are provider-scoped (ANTHROPIC_API_KEY
covers all Anthropic models), so this matches what the user actually
needs to fix.
- document the intentional asymmetry between eager and lazy signup
credit paths: eager skips both the signupCreditClaimedEmail and the
per-grant team@ alert. comment explains why (the 'new account
created' alert already covers it on the eager path; the user-facing
email assumes a user-initiated action that hasn't happened yet for
CLI/GH-App-only signups).
- skipping the backfill for the 15 historical accounts per user's
earlier decision — they all uninstalled, so the cohort self-selected
out of being reachable.
* fallback: gate on resolvedModel + skip resolveModel re-resolve post-swap
local agnostic fixture run surfaced two real bugs the unit tests didn't
catch:
1. fallback gate was on configuredSlug (=payload.model) but the test
uses PULLFROG_MODEL to set the model, which is read by resolveModel
AFTER its slug arg. configuredSlug stayed undefined → fallback never
fired. drop configuredSlug from the helper signature; gate purely on
resolvedModel since that's the same value regardless of how the
model was specified (DB config vs PULLFROG_MODEL env).
2. when fallback engaged, the post-swap resolveModel({slug: fallback.to})
call was ALSO honoring PULLFROG_MODEL, re-overriding the fallback
target back to the unkeyed model. validateAgentApiKey then threw
"no API key found" against the original model. fix: skip the
re-resolve. fallback.to is already a CLI-ready specifier.
unit tests updated for the new helper signature (8 tests, all pass).
fallback log line confirmed emitted in the local run pre-second-fix;
the second fix unblocks the validation that previously threw.
|
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
8dff91ac49 |
router: fix unspendable signup credit on no-card private repos (#792)
* router: fix unspendable signup credit on no-card private repos (#791) The bug ------- `run-context/route.ts` gated `proxyModel` minting on `isInfraCovered`, which is `oss || hasCard`. So a no-card account with positive wallet balance (signup credit, top-up, etc.) on a private repo would never get a `proxyModel` set on the run context. The action runtime then fell through to whatever provider keys happened to be in the workflow env — using the user's BYOK keys without their knowledge if any were configured, or failing the run entirely otherwise. Meanwhile `proxy-token/route.ts` already gated correctly on `oss || hasCard || balance > 0`. The two routes disagreed, with run-context being strictly more restrictive, so the agent never even attempted to call proxy-token for these accounts. The wiki at `billing.md:1052` documented the *intended* behavior ("a Router usage row can debit a wallet with no card on file"), aspirational against the actual code. The action side had a parallel bug at `action/utils/proxy.ts:151` — it re-derived `isInfraCovered({ isOss, plan })` and short-circuited mint even when the server set `proxyModel`. Belt-and-suspenders that was strictly more restrictive than the server. Production impact ----------------- Queried 55 router-mode no-card accounts holding signup credit: - ALL have wallet balance = exactly $10.00 (untouched) - ALL have 0 router proxy keys ever minted, 0 hwm usage - ~25 have successful runs (using BYOK env vars from their workflow, unaware their credit isn't being touched) - The rest have zero successes; some accumulated 25+ failures (e.g. `onechannelpe`: 25 failures, 0 successes, no card, $10 credit). The fix ------- - `run-context/route.ts`: widen `useRouter` to match proxy-token's gate. OSS short-circuits as before. Otherwise: router mode + card on file → mint; router mode + no card + positive balance → fetch balance, mint if > 0. Skip the balance read when a card is on file (auto-reload covers it without needing pre-flight balance — keeps the hot path single-query). - `action/utils/proxy.ts`: drop the redundant `isInfraCovered` check. `ctx.proxyModel` IS the signal — the server is the authority on funding decisions; the action just trusts and mints. - `wiki/pricing.md`: correct the Router proxy key minting gate row + add a paragraph explaining why this gate diverges from `isInfraCovered`. - `wiki/billing.md`: rewrite the misleading "proxy-token returns 402" paragraph to describe what actually happens at both routes. `isInfraCovered` is unchanged. It still gates Pullfrog-paid features (learnings writes, indexing). The bug was in conflating "Pullfrog pays for marginal infra" with "user can fund a Router run via wallet" — different concerns, now untangled. * action: drop dead isInfraCovered + plan param post-fix Cleanup the action-side dead code introduced by the previous commit's removal of the redundant `isInfraCovered` re-derivation in proxy.ts: - delete `isInfraCovered` from action/utils/runContext.ts (was the only callsite; mirror in server's utils/billing.ts is unchanged and still load-bearing for learnings/indexing) - drop unused `plan: AccountPlan` param from `resolveProxyModel` / `runProxyResolution` (and the corresponding `AccountPlan` import + the `plan: runContext.plan` arg at the main.ts call site) - update the action/mcp/server.ts comment that pointed at the now-gone action mirror to reference the server-side `utils/billing.ts` instead `AccountPlan` itself is still load-bearing (mcp/server, runContextData, run-context fetch), only `isInfraCovered` and the dead `plan` parameter go away. |
||
|
David Blass
|
dd26d35137 |
learnings: audit fixes — preamble in TOC, server-side line-boundary truncation, empty-repo intro (#743)
* learnings: surface preamble in TOC, mirror line-boundary truncation server-side, fix empty-repo intro copy three audit fixes on top of the recent learnings overhaul (#717): - `parseLearningsHeadings` now prepends a synthetic `(preamble)` entry when a body has non-whitespace content before the first heading. the prompt instructs the agent NOT to slurp the whole file when a TOC is present, so without this any preamble lines were silently invisible (realistic transitional case: an agent partially restructures a legacy free-text body and leaves bullets above the first `## `). - server-side PATCH route now applies the same line-boundary-aware truncation as the action (defense in depth via a shared `truncateAtLineBoundary` + `MAX_LEARNINGS_LENGTH` exported from `action/internal`). the raw `.slice` it used before could leave a mid-heading tail on any caller that bypassed the client-side truncate, breaking the next-seed TOC parse. removes the duplicated cap constant. - `buildLearningsSection` intro no longer asserts "accumulated by previous agent runs" — false for fresh repos with zero history. new copy is tense-neutral and works for empty + populated bodies. also nudges the agent to re-read after mid-run edits (the inlined TOC ranges are a run-start snapshot). Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * learnings prompt: tighten to single evergreen test, allow tool-quirk bullets when they prevent repeat waste The blanket "no pullfrog tool quirks" ban was wrong — if the agent burned calls discovering a quirk this run, recording the workaround prevents the next run from repeating the waste. Reframe around one litmus ("would a future run do its work better because this bullet exists?") and trust it to subsume the scattered don'ts. Drop the 3+ months timeframe (arbitrary) and the four-example pullfrog/PR/date/play-by-play list (the rule underneath is "don't anchor facts to repo state that will move"). Cuts ~10 lines from a prompt the model was already mostly ignoring; the remaining anchor list is narrower and more enforceable. * audit-learnings-r2: align wiki + tighten re-read nudge - wiki/prompt.md described the post-run reflection prompt as "bans pullfrog-tool quirks (those belong in tool descriptions, not per-repo learnings), bans PR/review/commit/date references" — that's stale after the prompt rewrite. update to: single-litmus framing, expanded anchor list (now includes version pins + line numbers), and explicit allowance for tool-quirk workarounds when discovery burned calls. - buildLearningsSection re-read nudge said "re-read after editing" which can be read as "re-read the section you edited". in fact any edit shifts the line numbers of every later section in the TOC, not just the edited one. tighten to make that explicit. mirror the new wording in the wiki example block. update the test substring assertion accordingly. * postRun: refresh JSDoc to match the reflection prompt rewrite `buildLearningsReflectionPrompt`'s JSDoc still listed "PR-/review-/commit-/date-anchored facts" and "rediscovery of pullfrog-tool quirks" as failure modes the prompt pushes back on. after b586b4f8 the prompt no longer bans tool-quirk bullets (it explicitly allows them when the agent burned calls discovering the quirk), and the anchor list expanded to cover branch refs, version pins, and line numbers too. update the JSDoc so it describes the prompt that actually exists, and call out the cross-repo drift tradeoff that comes with allowing tool-quirk bullets. * fix(mcp/issueEvents): narrow event.event before Set.has lookup octokit's listEventsForTimeline union includes timeline-event members where `event` is `event?: string`. `("event" in event)` does not narrow that property to non-undefined, so `relevantEventTypes.has(event.event)` was passing `string | undefined` to a `Set<string>.has`. typescript only flagged this once `cf-worker-indexing` started seeing the file via the type graph that now reaches mcp through the new `truncateAtLineBoundary` re-export in `action/internal/index.ts`. fix the latent bug at the source: require `typeof event.event === "string"` before the Set lookup. * learnings: split truncation helpers into MCP-free module re-exporting `truncateAtLineBoundary` + `MAX_LEARNINGS_LENGTH` from `action/utils/learnings.ts` through `action/internal/index.ts` accidentally pulled the entire MCP type graph into the SDK barrel: `learnings.ts` imports `ToolContext` from `mcp/server.ts`, which transitively wires every tool module under `action/mcp/` into anything that imports from `pullfrog/internal`. for `cf-worker-indexing/tsconfig.json` (`customConditions: ["@pullfrog/source"]`) and the root `tsc` (which compiles the proprietary app routes that import from `pullfrog/internal`), this expanded the type-checked surface and surfaced two latent issues in unrelated files (`mcp/issueEvents.ts`, `utils/subprocess.ts`). a 6-line pure string helper has no business dragging mcp/server.ts into anyone else's type graph. move both symbols to `action/utils/learningsTruncate.ts`. `learnings.ts` re-exports them so existing callers keep working; `internal/index.ts` re-exports from the truncate-only module so the SDK barrel stays MCP-free. --------- Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Colin McDonnell <colinmcd94@gmail.com> |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
8ac954a27f | fix(handleIncompleteSetup): also skip nudge when repos are disabled, not just active | ||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
88f170e19a |
fix: 7 log-audit / run-audit findings (mega-PR) (#769)
* fix(#765): silence Clerk 400 (revoked OAuth) noise from getTokenForClerkId Branch on isClerkAPIResponseError + status<500 so the well-understood revoked-token redirect doesn't emit a level=error line in Better Stack on every request. Vercel maps console.warn -> error for non-streaming routes, so a downgrade to log.warn wouldn't help; only the unexpected shape (5xx, network) is worth surfacing. * fix(#742): stop logging input verbatim from yes.op retry-failure paths GitHub OAuth user tokens (ghu_...) were leaking to Better Stack on every yes.op retry-failure for any utils/github/get* helper that takes a token field — 38 leaks/7d in the most recent audit window. The leak path is console.log inside the yes package (its own log shim, not utils/log.ts). Drop input from the four log sites + the cache-key-derivation throw site. key (SHA-1 of input) is sufficient for retry correlation; error already carries request URL + status. Defense-in-depth comment so future contributors don't re-add the field. Operational follow-up (separate task): inventory ghu_... strings in Better Stack ingested in the last 90d, revoke matching Clerk grants, scrub cold-tier S3, rotate the BS source token. * fix(#759): handle GraphqlResponseError "Could not resolve to a node" as 404 When the stored planCommentNodeId references a comment that's been deleted on GitHub, octokit.graphql throws GraphqlResponseError before the existing `node === null` 404 branch is reached. Add a narrow isGraphqlNodeNotFound predicate in utils/errors.ts and a new catch branch in the plan-comment route. The action treats 404 as "no prior plan comment" and creates a fresh one, so behavior matches existing contract. * fix(#747): convert webhook GraphQL rate-limit 5xx into a Result<T> sentinel + 200 ack When GitHub's GraphQL responds with "API rate limit exceeded for installation ID N", _getReviewCommentsWithReplies threw, propagated through the bare yes.op wrapper (no rate-limit bail), out of the bare await in handleWebhook, and crashed /api/webhook/github with 500 — 77 webhook 500s/24h on the most recent audit window. GitHub redelivery plus R2 dedup also silently masked the legitimate handler from re-running once the rate-limit window cleared. Mirror the #658 / _getRepository pattern: detect GraphqlResponseError matching /rate limit (already )?exceeded/i, log.warn with the x-ratelimit-reset value (and [Installation N] prefix when available), return failure(...) with status 429. Webhook handler short-circuits the case with 200 + log.info so GitHub stops the redelivery storm against an exhausted budget, and the trigger page surfaces a clean ThrowClientError. Document the new pattern as a Tier 2 false-positive in wiki/log-audit.md so the next audit cron doesn't re-flag it. Note that returning [] silently (the issue's first suggestion) would have dropped @pullfrog mentions inline in review comments and dispatched an agent run that re-rate-limits — skip-the-whole-case is the correct semantics. Co-vulnerable getPullRequest / getWorkflow have zero occurrences in this window; per #737 policy, defer until they show up. NOTE: this commit and the bracket of touched files revert as a unit — the Result<T> shape change in getReviewCommentsWithReplies is breaking; partial revert breaks the type chain. * fix(#766): fold stderr+stdout into shell.ts errors + carve out merge-base --is-ancestor action/utils/shell.ts dropped stdout when constructing failure messages ($\{stderr || "Unknown error"\}), so git subcommands that write context-bearing diagnostics to stdout (merge conflicts, cherry-pick rejections, diff --exit-code, ls-files --error-unmatch) surfaced as "Command failed with exit code 1: Unknown error" through mcp__pullfrog__git. The agent burned an extra MCP round-trip calling git status to recover. Fold stderr + stdout into the thrown error message (stderr first, stdout fallback) so the agent always sees the real diagnostic. Plus a narrow carve-out for `git merge-base --is-ancestor` in action/mcp/git.ts: that subcommand uses exit code as data (0=ancestor, 1=not-an-ancestor, >1=error), so return { success: true, isAncestor } instead of throwing on exit 1. No caller in action/ string-matches on the old error format (verified). diff --exit-code and ls-files --error-unmatch are not carved out — both are zero-occurrence in the May audit window, and the stderr+stdout fold renders their output usefully anyway. * fix(#739): point customers at the actual fix when permissions: id-token: write is missing When a customer workflow runs in GitHub Actions but lacks permissions: id-token: write, ACTIONS_ID_TOKEN_REQUEST_URL/_TOKEN aren't injected, isOIDCAvailable() is false, and acquireNewToken falls through to the local-dev-only acquireTokenViaGitHubApp path, which throws "GITHUB_APP_ID and GITHUB_PRIVATE_KEY must be set" — pointing at a self-hosted-app fix that doesn't apply. One affected customer burned 13 dispatches in 24h on this misleading error. Detect (GITHUB_ACTIONS=true) AND (no OIDC env vars) inside acquireNewToken before falling through to the local-dev branch, and throw an actionable message naming the missing permissions block, the exact YAML, and the docs anchor. The error surfaces via ##[error]action failed: ... in the workflow log (the only customer surface available before main()'s inner try opens). Local-dev path keeps the existing GITHUB_APP_ID message. * fix(#760): suspend activity watchdog across in-flight tool calls mcp__pullfrog__checkout_pr was hard-failing 6/24h on SenecaLabs/senecaWeb because git fetch+deepen on a large monorepo can take 4-5 min, the agent's stdout pipe goes silent the entire time (FastMCP is in-process HTTP, but Claude/opencode CLIs await the synchronous tools/call response), and both the spawn-level activity timer (300s in subprocess.ts) and the process-level activity monitor (300s in activity.ts) fire and kill the run. Re-introduce the bracket pattern that PR #634 removed: bracket suspendActivity()/resumeActivity() around tool_use -> tool_result in both agent harnesses, plumb isPausedExternally into spawn() so both timers suspend in lockstep. Bounded by MAX_TOOL_CALL_SUSPENSION_MS (15 min auto-resume) plus the outer 1h agent timeout — neither zombie-run avenue from #12 is reopened (subprocess.close still resolves on death; outer timeout is suspend-agnostic; suspends gated on explicit paired CLI events, not internal noise). opencode tool_use handler: gate suspendActivity() on non-terminal status (running/pending) so the bus_event re-dispatch path at line 915 — which only fires for completed/error subagent parts and never emits a paired tool_result — doesn't latch the watchdog into suspension until the 15min ceiling. Add a heuristic:activity-watchdog-ceiling classifier to scripts/analyze-logs.ts so a tool that genuinely hangs past MAX_TOOL_CALL_SUSPENSION_MS surfaces in run-audit instead of being bucketed into failure:unknown. NOTE: this commit and the bracket of touched files revert as a unit — activity.ts, subprocess.ts, and the two harnesses must move together or the bracketing breaks. * refactor(#747): swap Result<T> for InstallationRateLimitError typed throw The Result<T> shape from 3ebf6c4c was cargo-culted from the #658 _getRepository pattern, but _getReviewCommentsWithReplies has only one expected-error case (installation rate-limit) and two callers — Result imposes branching on the trigger-page caller that never cared about the rate-limit case specifically. A typed error class is lighter (~10 LoC vs ~33) and matches the actual need: - new InstallationRateLimitError(resetAt) thrown from _getReviewCommentsWithReplies; rate-limit log.warn unchanged. - handleWebhook catches it and breaks with log.info (unchanged semantics: 200 ack, no redelivery storm). - trigger page reverts to direct array access; any failure propagates to the page error boundary (the pre-#747-commit shape). - log-audit.md wording updated to match. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
c0988e35b0 |
fix(security): block docker socket from sandboxed shell; disable opencode batch_tool
two real CI failures on main, both shipping bugs in the action: 1. `token-exfil-claude` was a real sandbox escape: GHA `ubuntu-latest` puts `runner` in the `docker` group, so a sandboxed shell could run `docker run --pid=host --privileged busybox cat /proc/<parent>/environ` and read the action process's env (which holds user secrets) — fully bypassing the unshare PID-namespace. fix: inside the sandbox's mount namespace (already private via `--mount-proc` which implies `--mount`), bind-mount /dev/null over /var/run/docker.sock (+ podman/containerd/crio variants) so any container-runtime socket connect from the sandbox fails. only affects sandboxed shells — host runner mount table is untouched, so user workflow steps outside pullfrog keep working. 2. `restricted-opencode` regressed in #719 (`experimental.batch_tool`). opencode's batch tool rejects MCP tools with `"Tool '<name>' not in registry. External tools (MCP, environment) cannot be batched."` when a model emits parallel `pullfrog_shell` (or any MCP) tool_use blocks, opencode internally routes them through batch, they all fail, the model misreads the error as "the tool doesn't exist", and gives up. caught by a `lens:` subagent in the restricted test concluding shell was unavailable and setting `DIAGNOSTIC_ID=empty`. drop `batch_tool: true` and the matching opencode-specific guidance in `instructions.ts` — native parallel tool_use (multiple tool_use blocks per assistant message) still works for both built-in and MCP tools without batch, so we lose only the 1-25 wrapper, not parallelism. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
ddbc610569 |
review prompt: friendly green callouts + per-section severity emojis (#756)
* review prompt: friendly green callouts + per-section severity emojis - Replace `[!NOTE]` informational tier and the no-callout minor-suggestions tier with friendly green blockquotes (`> ✅` / `> 💡`). The two loud tiers (`[!CAUTION]` / `[!IMPORTANT]`) keep their GitHub admonitions. - Add a per-`##`-section severity-emoji rule (🚨/⚠️/💡/ℹ️) for cross-cutting review concerns that don't anchor to a line and would otherwise be buried in summary content. - Drop the `<br/>` between summary sections — heading + blank line carries enough visual spacing. - Skip the post-run learnings-reflection turn for `IncrementalReview`. It's the lowest-novelty mode (delta review against existing PR with prior summary already loaded) and almost never produces durable learnings — reflection there costs ~$0.50-0.80/run for nothing. - Surface real error info on `agent-browser` skill install failures (exit code + stdout + stderr + spawn error). The skills CLI uses a TUI that prints errors to stdout, so the prior stderr-only logging silently swallowed every failure. * review prompt: per-bullet severity emoji + bullets-only sections Section headings are plain again (no leading severity emoji). Severity moves to individual bullets so a section that mixes a 🚨 and a 💡 isn't mislabeled by either. Section bodies are now bullets only — paragraph prose under a heading is harder to scan and tends to bury the actionable point. Bullets can carry indented continuation content (sub-bullets, code fences, blockquotes) by indenting two spaces under the parent. * review prompt: cap section length + identifier discipline Bound each summary section to at most 4 bullets at most 2 lines each, and explicitly call out identifier-heavy prose as an anti-pattern. The reader is often a manager or non-author; identifier-dense paragraphs ('foo calls bar.fetch which dispatches to baz via qux...') are unreadable for them. Default to plain-language behavior descriptions, name an identifier only when it's the subject of an actionable concern or a public surface a reader would recognize, target 2-3 backtick tokens per bullet. Move the deep-explanation pattern from open blockquote to a default- collapsed details/summary so depth doesn't dominate the visible body. * review prompt: hard cap on bullet identifier density + worked rewrite example Soft 'aim for 2-3 tokens' guidance was ignored — first big-PR e2e showed 12 of 19 actionable bullets exceeded the target (avg 4.8 tokens, several over 8). Promote to a hard cap of 3 backticked tokens per bullet and pair with a concrete bad/good rewrite the agent can pattern- match against. Also tighten the per-bullet length cap from ~240 to ~200 chars and explicitly call it 'hard cap, not target'. * review prompt: tighten bullet length cap to 160 chars, dramatize the worked example V2 e2e test: token discipline improved (4.8 -> 3.3 avg, 12/19 -> 6/14 violations) but length got worse (235 -> 286 chars, 13/14 over the 200 cap). The agent compensated for fewer identifiers with more prose. Two changes: (1) tighten the cap from ~200 chars to 160 chars / 1 visual line and call out wrap-to-multiple-lines as the failure mode; (2) rewrite the worked example so the good version is genuinely half the length of the bad one, not just lower token count. The example was the thing the agent pattern-matches against; making the good version ~130 chars vs the bad version's ~290 chars sets the right shape. * review prompt: drop fixed bullet-count cap, keep length + identifier caps Per user feedback — section length should be governed by content, not an arbitrary count. Soft guidance ('past ~6, ask whether to split') is fine; the hard '≤ 4 bullets per section' rule was the wrong shape. Length cap (160c) and identifier cap (3 backtick tokens) stay; those target the actual scanability problem. * review prompt: drop ## subsystem sections, flat 'Issues found' list Per-section structure forced every concern into a subsystem frame and made the body read like a series of mini-essays. Replace with two parts: (1) TL;DR + Key changes as the dispassionate overview, (2) flat '### Issues found' list ordered by severity, intermixed across files and subsystems. Per-bullet rules (≤160c, ≤3 backtick tokens, severity emoji prefix, optional indented continuation) carry over unchanged. * review prompt: full v6 structure — preamble + cross-cutting H3s + nitpicks Replaces the flat 'Issues found' bullet list with the iterated v6 shape: - Preamble is a bolded inline 'Reviewed changes' lead-in plus bullets plus a collapsed 'Review metadata' block (mode/files/commits/refs/ reviewed commits list/prior pullfrog review/staleness note). - Each cross-cutting concern gets a '### emoji Title' section. The visible problem write-up is human-friendly and DESCRIBES THE PROBLEM ONLY — no asks, no suggested fixes, no 'the right thing to do is'. - Each section carries a collapsed 'Technical details' block wrapped in a 4-backtick markdown fence (so it can hold its own 3-tick code fences cleanly, agent-readable, one-click copyable). Standard four inner sections: Affected sites, Required outcome, optional Suggested approach, optional Open questions for the human. - '### ℹ️ Nitpicks' at the bottom for body-only nits that don't inline; simple bullets, no technical-details collapse. - Anti-paragraph-wall rule: never two successive plain paragraphs in visible '### ' sections; alternate prose with structure. - Inline-vs-body discipline: anything that anchors to a single line goes inline, body is for cross-cutting only. - Drops legacy '### Key changes', '### Issues found', '<b>TL;DR</b>', and the '<sub>Summary</sub>' line. * model effort: bump Gemini + GPT to high effort; drop Gemini Pro→Flash subagent E2E review eval against a substantive billing-module diff surfaced two related quality gaps: 1. Gemini Pro at thinkingLevel=medium (#663's CI-timeout fix) reviewed the diff only, took the 0-lens path, and missed a catastrophic camelCase/snake_case service-vs-schema mismatch. Bumping back to high — review work is exactly the wrong shape for the medium/high tradeoff #663 was optimizing for; the per-turn TTFT cost is worth paying when reasoning IS the value. 2. GPT had no reasoningEffort override, defaulting to upstream medium. Same diff, similar shallow result vs Claude. Adding reasoningEffort: high for the curated direct-OpenAI slugs, mirroring the Gemini pattern (Anthropic separately uses --effort high via the Claude Code CLI flag in claude.ts). 3. Gemini Pro's subagentModel was 'gemini-flash' — but Google has no in-between tier between Pro and Flash, and Flash is a meaningful capability cliff for review work. Dropping the override so subagents inherit Pro. Cost stays reasonable since Gemini Pro is already the cheapest of the flagship trio. Other providers unchanged: Anthropic opus→sonnet and OpenAI gpt→gpt-5.4 remain (each is a one-tier drop to a still-capable sibling). * model effort: revert orchestrator override, set explicit high on reviewfrog subagent Reshape the effort design after eval: - Drop the explicit Gemini and GPT model-level overrides — orchestrators now run at upstream defaults (Gemini high, GPT-5.x medium). Gemini's upstream IS high, so this is a no-op there; GPT goes back to upstream medium for orchestrator-level routing work. - Add explicit 'high' on the reviewfrog subagent via agent.options. OpenCode merge order is base ← model.options ← agent.options ← variant per session/llm.ts:141, so the subagent always runs at high regardless of which orchestrator dispatched it. Both thinkingConfig.thinkingLevel (Gemini) and reasoningEffort (GPT) keys included; irrelevant keys are ignored per provider. - Bump providers-live timeouts (12min job / 10min step, from 8/6) to budget for Gemini's TTFT variance at high effort. #663's 4min timeout was sized for the medium-effort override that's now removed. * model effort: restore Gemini explicit high override (no-override path breaks) Bare 'rely on upstream default' for Gemini failed in e2e — removing the model-level provider config produced 'Function call is missing a thought_signature' API errors on every gemini-pro run. Even though upstream opencode's options() returns the same thinkingLevel: high we were explicitly setting, opencode's resolution path differs subtly between the two cases. v2's explicit override worked; v3's removal broke. Reproducible across two consecutive runs. Restoring the explicit Gemini override (back to v2 design). GPT orchestrator stays UN-overridden — at upstream default (medium) — since removing that override didn't trigger the same failure pattern and the reviewfrog subagent agent.options high override compensates for the extra depth GPT loses at medium. * diag: remove reviewfrog agent.options to isolate Gemini thought_signature failure v3 (no Gemini orch override) failed with thought_signature error. v4 (restored Gemini orch override at v2-equivalent) ALSO failed, even though the orchestrator config matches v2. The variable between v2 (working) and v4 (failing) is the new reviewfrog agent.options block. Removing it to confirm — if Gemini works again, the agent.options addition is the culprit and we need a different shape for it. * opencode-ai: bump 1.1.56 → 1.15.0 + clean up gemini effort config opencode-ai@1.1.56 was published 2026-02-10 (3 months old). The Google API tightened thought_signature validation 24-48h ago (per https://discuss.ai.google.dev/t/gemini-thought-signature-patch/122555), and the bug class hits opencode's session→prompt serializer for MCP tool-call parts (anomalyco/opencode#4832, #8321). Latest stable bumps us through ~3 months of fixes; needed for Gemini-direct to stop dying with 'thought_signature is missing' on every multi-turn run. Companion cleanup: the gemini provider override in opencode.ts had 30-line block of comments, four unused constants, and a 6-line Object.fromEntries map for two entries. Replaced with one source-of- truth helper that loops modelAliases, filters provider==='google', strips the 'google/' prefix, and returns the override map. Adding any future Google alias to the registry now flows through automatically. Test added: action/agents/opencode.test.ts asserts the helper covers every direct-Google alias, strips the prefix correctly, and pins every entry to thinkingLevel high — catches drift in helper logic without hardcoding the API ids the test would have to update in lockstep with the registry. * fix(workflow): tolerate listJobsForWorkflowRun 404 in resolveRun PR #750 (docker testing rewrite) replaced the per-call env allowlist with full process.env passthrough into the test container. That now leaks GITHUB_RUN_ID + GITHUB_JOB into runs whose MCP token is scoped to a DIFFERENT repo (e.g. providers-live smoke runs the action against pullfrog/test-repo with pullfrog/app's run ID). The unconditional listJobsForWorkflowRun call 404s and crashes the entire run, breaking every providers-live job on main since #750 landed. jobId is purely cosmetic (deep-links 'View workflow run' footer to a specific job vs the run-level URL). Wrapping the API call in try/catch so a 404 logs a debug message and falls through to undefined jobId is the right fix — the failure mode is exactly what graceful degradation is for, and the alternative (filter the env vars at the docker boundary) re-introduces the kind of allowlist #750 was getting rid of. * opencode-ai: pin 1.14.51 instead of 1.15.0 (effect refactor breaks JSON output) opencode 1.15.0 (May 15) ships a major architectural refactor onto @effect — the run command boots an in-process server via @opencode-ai/sdk/v2 and the JSON event emission path through that SDK client doesn't surface on stdout the way our parser expects (CI run on 1.15.0 produced 0 stdout events but the agent still completed). Local invocation also hangs at the in-process server boot. The Gemini thought_signature fixes (the original reason for bumping) landed earlier in the 1.14.x line, so 1.14.51 (May 14) gets us the upstream fix without the Effect rewrite. Defer the 1.15.x bump until we're ready to rewire our parser/spawn around the new SDK. * opencode-ai: revert to 1.1.56; gha: filter outer-CI workflow-run vars at the docker boundary Two related changes for the docker testing harness's ergonomics: 1. Revert opencode-ai 1.14.51 → 1.1.56. The 1.14+ line ships an Effect refactor (the SDK-v2 client + in-process server architecture) that our --format json parser doesn't speak — even the 1.14.51 release, pre-dating the 1.15.0 Effect rename, produced 0 stdout events on our skill-invoke smoke. There's no clean pre-Effect version that ships the Gemini thought_signature fix; that fix needs a separate workstream once we're ready to rewire the parser onto SDK v2. 2. Filter outer-CI workflow-run identifiers (GITHUB_RUN_ID, GITHUB_JOB, GITHUB_WORKFLOW, GITHUB_ACTION, GITHUB_REF, GITHUB_SHA, etc.) from gha.ts's --env-file passthrough. PR #750's full-process.env design leaks pullfrog/app's CI run identifiers into runs that act against a different repo (e.g. pullfrog/test-repo); any code path inside the action that uses them as keys (most notably resolveRun's listJobsForWorkflowRun lookup) 404s. Filtering them here means the action sees undefined and skips the lookup, complementing the defensive try/catch in resolveRun (commit addc76d4). GITHUB_REPOSITORY and GITHUB_TOKEN are NOT filtered — those are genuinely needed. Companion to addc76d4 (resolveRun 404 tolerance). The two together make this class of bug 'either fix would have caught it' rather than 'silently breaks the entire test matrix'. * fix(deps): sync pnpm-lock.yaml with opencode-ai 1.1.56 manifest revert Forgot to refresh the lockfile after reverting the manifest in 02c6d8c1. CI's frozen-lockfile install was failing with 'lockfile: 1.14.51, manifest: 1.1.56' mismatch. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
74b7329f64 |
fix(action): dedupe concurrent checkout_pr + guard cross-PR clobber (#735)
* fix(action): dedupe concurrent checkout_pr calls + guard cross-PR clobber (#642) agents occasionally emit duplicate parallel `checkout_pr` tool_use blocks in one turn, causing two `checkoutPrBranch` invocations to race the same `.git/shallow.lock` and one to fail with `File exists`. the prior fix (#564) added a 30s staleness sweep, but that very threshold protects the within-run concurrent case from itself. dedupe at the tool layer: a module-level `Map<pull_number, Promise>` shares a single in-flight promise across concurrent same-PR calls. the fetch race becomes architecturally impossible — first call does the work, duplicate gets the same `CheckoutPrResult`. cleared in `finally` so subsequent same-PR calls re-do the work normally. also reject cross-PR checkouts when the working tree is dirty, surfacing a clear error instead of silently overwriting uncommitted work from a prior PR. uses existing `toolState.issueNumber` (no new state). * review: use dedicated `pullNumber` toolState field for cross-PR guard per copilot review: the prior guard used `toolState.issueNumber`, which is also set by issue/comment lookup tools (issueInfo, issueComments, issueEvents, review). that conflation is intentional and correct for its only consumer (`report_progress` falls back to `issueNumber` to choose which issue/PR to comment on, and GitHub treats both via the same comment API). but it makes the field wrong for the cross-PR guard: a same-PR re-checkout after `get_issue(other)` would falsely fire and surface a misleading "from PR #other" message. introduce a separate `pullNumber` field, set only by `checkoutPrBranch` alongside `issueNumber` and `checkoutSha`. narrower invariant, no disturbance to the existing `issueNumber` semantics. * review: drop dual-write — single `issueNumber` is sufficient for the guard reverting the `pullNumber` addition. setting both `issueNumber` and `pullNumber` to the same value at the same site was a code smell — there is no scenario where they diverge. issues and PRs share GitHub's number space, and the cross-PR guard's actual job is "refuse to clobber a dirty tree when switching to a different number"; that's expressible with `issueNumber` alone. addresses copilot's original concern (misleading "from PR #X" message when X was an issue) by removing the prior-number reference from the error message entirely. the dirty paths are the actionable detail. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
4ad649ebb9 |
action: extend shallow-unreachable deepen-retry to checkout_pr fetches (#734)
extracts the deepen-retry helper from `GitFetchTool` into shared `$gitFetchWithDeepen` and applies it to every fetch in `checkoutPrBranch` (baseRef, pull/N/head, before_sha temp branch). on shallow clones with deep PR ancestry — the failure mode behind ~10 of 51 `heuristic:very-slow` runs in 24h on `remotion-dev/remotion` — the baseRef fetch was throwing `Could not read <sha>` to the agent before the compare-api deepen block could run. agents then burned 10+ minutes retrying `checkout_pr` and falling back to ad-hoc shell `git fetch --deepen` workarounds. also splits the analyzer's `heuristic:git-error-recovered` into `heuristic:git-shallow-unreachable` and `heuristic:git-shallow-lock` buckets so future audits surface this without manual log-grep. closes #656. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
2960d51493 |
shell tool: cap output at 5K chars and spill overflow to tempfile (#732)
unbounded shell tool output blows the agent's context window on commands
that dump big logs (test runners, build tools, grep on large trees). cap
the inline body at 5000 chars; on overflow, persist the full output to
${PULLFROG_TEMP_DIR}/shell-<id>.log and return the tail prefixed with a
sentinel pointing at the saved path. agents re-read the tempfile with
cat/tail/grep when they need more.
|
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
206c11fe7c |
review: drop misleading 'with the same arguments' from diff-coverage nudge
agent is free to refine review body/comments on retry — there's no enforcement that the second call matches the first, and if reading the nudged region surfaces a new finding the agent should add it. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
7414c1e9ca |
review: clarify diff-coverage nudge gives explicit license to skip generated artifacts
the one-time pre-flight nudge said "optionally read" but never told the agent it's free to retry without reading when every unread region is generated (lockfiles, codegen, snapshots, migration metadata). audit #677 surfaced ~21 runs/24h burning an extra model turn re-reading drizzle snapshots, pnpm-lock, and *.gen.ts files purely to satisfy the gate. mode prompts only mention generated content in the "skip self-review entirely" path, not the "in-progress substantive review" path, so the in-the-moment error message was the gap. behavior unchanged for legitimately-unread source regions. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
b9f0938405 |
mcp: restore operational guidance dropped in #723
#723's revision pass cut four substantive strings along with the negative anchors. those strings address real, audit-observed failure modes and the positive examples don't carry them. restored: - push_branch: "if the response reports a timeout, the underlying push may have actually succeeded — verify with git log origin/<branch> before retrying" (was on the tool description) - create_pull_request_review commit_id .describe(): "must be the FULL 40-character SHA — abbreviated SHAs are rejected by GitHub with 422" - create_pull_request_review comments[].line .describe(): "must sit inside a `@@` hunk... dropped entries are reported under droppedComments in the response" - create_pull_request_review comments[].start_line .describe(): "both start_line and line must sit inside the same @@ hunk" also: get_commit_info example used a 31-character SHA (non-standard truncation). swapped to a 7-char short form, which is what git log --oneline emits and what agents see in practice. note that this tool accepts either full or abbreviated, unlike create_pull_request_review which requires full. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
b8ac42e875 |
mcp: embed example calls in top-level tool descriptions (#723)
* mcp: embed example calls in top-level tool descriptions
agents (esp. claude sonnet) hallucinate param names from training-data
priors — `pr_number` instead of `pull_number`, `summary` instead of
`body`, full subcommand strings jammed into `git({command})` like it
were `shell({command})`. each error burns a tool round-trip plus a
follow-up ToolSearch, ~40+ events / 24h, no observable recovery cost
to us but visible to users in agent logs.
cheapest fix: add a sample formatted function call to every affected
tool's top-level description. example anchors are more reliable than
schema descriptions alone because the model treats descriptions as
narrative but call examples as canonical structure. for `git` and
`shell` (whose `command` fields collide), include explicit
counter-examples disambiguating which tool owns which shape.
no schema aliases / coercion yet — try the cheap thing first; if the
next audit window still shows the same hallucination rate, layer
aliases on top per #585's recommendation.
closes #585, closes #701
* mcp: drop negative anchors from tool descriptions
negation is a footgun in tool descriptions — telling the model "NOT
pr_number" makes pr_number more salient, not less. let the positive
example carry the schema and trust the model to read it.
removes:
- "the parameter is pull_number (a number), NOT pr_number" and
similar across checkout_pr, get_pull_request, list_pull_request_reviews,
get_review_comments, create_pull_request_review
- "NOT summary, message, or content" on report_progress
- "WRONG: git({ command: 'log --oneline' })" counter-example on git
- redundant param-type restatements after the example (e.g. "depth is a
number, not a string" on git_fetch, "description is required" on shell)
keeps a single positive example per tool. for tools with multiple call
shapes (git, git_fetch, push_branch), two positive examples instead of
one + a counter-example.
|
||
|
David Blass
|
5518890b18 |
learnings: TOC + section taxonomy + 100k cap, hygiene rules, tool-quirk descriptions (#717)
* audit learnings: reshape reflection prompt + bake tool quirks into descriptions (#619) Cross-repo audit of the 48 repos with non-null learnings turned up two recurring failure modes: 1. ~25-30% of bullets across the most-active repos are pullfrog-tool quirks ("shell timeout is in milliseconds", "git args must be a JSON array", "create_pull_request_review drops out-of-hunk comments", "push_branch may report timeout when push succeeded", "checkout_pr shallow.lock retries", "commit_id needs full 40-char SHA"). These are universal across repos and should live in tool descriptions, not be rediscovered and stored 48 times. Tool descriptions now surface them. 2. Bullets are routinely 200-1000 chars (paragraph-length), and 12 of 48 repos are at the 10k cap. The reflection prompt now: caps bullets at ~240 chars (one specific fact), bans PR/review/commit/date-anchored facts that decay within weeks, bans tool-quirk learnings, and tells the agent that cap pressure means compress+prune existing bullets, not skip new findings. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * learnings: add server-generated TOC, fixed section taxonomy, raise cap to 100k (#707) Cap goes 10k → 100k. Reads stay bounded because the seeded file now opens with a server-generated table of contents listing every `## ` section's line range — agents read the TOC, then `read_file offset/limit` just the sections relevant to the current task instead of slurping the whole file. ## Section taxonomy (fixed) `## Build & test`, `## CI`, `## Conventions`, `## Architecture`, `## Gotchas`. Free-form `### ` sub-headings inside a section are fine. Pre-taxonomy free-text rows get wrapped in a `## Legacy` carve-out on first seed so they remain visible while the agent gradually re-curates them during reflection turns. ## Storage shape unchanged `Repo.learnings` still holds raw markdown (no schema migration). The TOC is a pure read-side affordance: prepended at seed time, stripped from the agent-edited file before persist. Markers `<!-- pullfrog-learnings-toc:* -->` delimit the strip region. Agent edits inside the markers are discarded. ## Round-trip semantics `seedLearningsFile` now returns `{ path, canonicalSeed }` where `canonicalSeed` is the post-TOC body — same shape `readLearningsFile` returns at end-of-run, so `persistLearnings` byte-compares them directly to skip the no-op PATCH. Empty-repo first runs end up with the section scaffold both as seed and as read-back, so untouched runs still short-circuit cleanly. ## Reflection prompt Adds explicit section-placement guidance (place each new bullet under the most relevant `## `; do NOT add new top-level headings; do NOT edit anything between the TOC markers). Carries forward the bullet hygiene from the previous commit: ≤240 chars per bullet, no pullfrog-tool quirks (those belong in tool descriptions), no PR/review/commit/date references. The "near cap" framing is replaced with "compress and prune within a section when it grows noisy" since the cap pressure that drove cramming is gone. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * anneal round 1: line-anchored taxonomy detect, partial-merge, line-boundary truncation, scaffold-empty UI Multi-lens review of the TOC + taxonomy diff surfaced a cluster of correctness and operational bugs. Fixes: - `hasAnyTaxonomyHeading` used `String.includes("## X")` which false-positives on `### X` (the `## ` substring sits inside `### `), prose containing `## CI`, fenced code documenting markdown, etc. Replaced with a line-anchored predicate that reuses `parseHeadings` so detection and TOC construction stay consistent. - The "any heading present → pass through verbatim" rule meant a body with one taxonomy heading would seed without the other four. Worse, requiring all five would flip a body back into Legacy when the agent legitimately pruned a section to empty. New `partial` kind: keep existing content in place, append missing sections in canonical order so the agent always has the full scaffold without losing pruning intent. - `stripLearningsToc` collapsed `\n{3,}` globally; `canonicalSeed` doesn't, so an untouched body with intentional triple-newline spacing would compare unequal and burn a spurious LearningsRevision row each run. Drop the global collapse — only the leading newlines that the strip itself introduces are normalized. - 100k truncation via `slice(0, 100_000)` could cut mid-line, breaking `parseHeadings` (whole-line `^## `) on the next seed and flipping a cut body back into Legacy. New `truncateAtLineBoundary` cuts at the last newline before the cap. - `LearningsSection.tsx` rendered a scaffold-only body as "has learnings" instead of the empty placeholder. Added a `hasOnlyEmptyScaffold` guard so the console behaves the same as pre-PR for the empty case. - Seed log line distinguishes `kind=structured/partial/legacy-wrapped/ empty` instead of `existing=yes/no`, so operators can spot legacy migration activity in logs. - New tests cover: substring false-positive (`### Build & test`, in-prose mentions), partial-taxonomy merge (no Legacy wrap), full-taxonomy structured pass-through, last-newline truncation, triple-newline preservation. Deferred (documented in PR body): deploy-ordering footgun (action before API), rollback for rows >10k, Gemini sanitizer dropping `description` on `anyOf` branches, reflection-on-failed-runs. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * anneal r2: hard-truncate fallback when line boundary discards >4k Round-2 review caught a regression in `truncateAtLineBoundary`: when the only newline within the first 100k chars sits near the start (e.g. one heading + 100k+ char single line — pathological pasted log dumps), the line-boundary cut discards almost all of the body. losing one partial line is preferable to losing kilobytes; threshold the fallback at 4k. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * move TOC out of file: prompt-side rendering, server-parsed headings drops the in-file TOC + fixed taxonomy in favor of: - file on disk = verbatim Repo.learnings (no markers, no scaffold) - server parses headings (mdast-util-from-markdown) at run-context time and returns them as RepoSettings.learningsHeadings - action renders heading TOC into the LEARNINGS prompt section as parenthesized line ranges like `Build & test (L1-L42)` with hierarchy via 2-space indent off the shallowest depth - reflection prompt teaches agent-curated structure with a soft 300-line per-section cap and explicit guidance to restructure flat legacy lists cuts 8 helpers (ensureSections, stripLearningsToc, assembleFile, buildTocBlock, parseHeadings, buildSectionScaffold, hasAnyTaxonomyHeading, LEARNINGS_SECTIONS) and the canonicalSeed round-trip dance. action seedLearningsFile is now { path } only; main.ts byte-compares the trimmed read-back against (current ?? "").trim() to gate the persist PATCH. truncateAtLineBoundary kept for safety. new tests: - test/learningsToc.test.ts (11 parser cases incl. fenced-code, blockquote, arbitrary h1-h6 nesting, startLine-points-at-heading invariant) - action/utils/learningsTocRender.test.ts (7 renderer cases) --------- Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: Colin McDonnell <colinmcd94@gmail.com> |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
159389fad2 |
fix(mcp): sanitize for gemini when model is unresolved (#697)
* fix(mcp): sanitize for gemini when model is unresolved isGeminiRouted() previously required the effective model string to contain "gemini" — but when payload.model="auto" (or any unresolved slug) reaches addTools(), `effective` is the literal "auto", which doesn't match. opencode then auto-selects gemini *after* the MCP server has registered raw arktype schemas, and every tool turn dies on `function_declarations[*].properties[*].any_of[*].enum: only allowed for STRING type`. widen the gate: any unresolved specifier (undefined / "auto" / a slug without a `provider/` prefix) is treated as gemini-routed and sanitized. the transforms are universally compatible normalizations so the false-positive cost is negligible. tighten case 3 to preserve `description` so the only lossy path no longer drops operator-facing context. fixes #676. * revert case-3 description preservation per pullfrog review on #697: keeping `description` as a peer of `anyOf`/`oneOf` directly contradicts the file's own header (lines 19-21) and the upstream opencode #14659 rationale that gates this sanitizer — gemini requires anyOf to be the ONLY field on a schema node, sibling keywords trigger `anyOf must be the only field in a schema node`. the change was speculative scope creep with no evidence, and would silently re-introduce a different gemini failure for any future schema using `.describe().or(...)`. the bug fix for #676 doesn't need it (arktype doesn't emit non-collapsible anyOf for current tool schemas). |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
cf94773bf0 |
modes: make task-list authoring the explicit first step in every mode checklist (#665)
* modes: make task-list authoring the explicit first step in every mode checklist The system prompt already instructs the agent to author an internal task list at the start of every run (action/utils/instructions.ts:291), but the rule lives several hundred tokens above the agent's first decision point and references the mode's checklist before the agent has it. Compliance is roughly coin-flip across opus runs — PR #610 dead-air for 9m20s was the extreme case; my own #664 e2e runs split 1-for-1 on `todowrite` compliance. Putting the directive *inside* the checklist that `select_mode` returns co-locates instruction with referent at the moment the agent decides what to do next. Same vocabulary as the existing rule (`task list`, agent-agnostic; the harness already maps to `todowrite`/`TodoWrite` per-agent in agents/opencode.ts and agents/claude.ts). The directive is deliberately non-prescriptive about list contents — the agent authors items based on the work it's about to do, not from a hand-shaped template. Touches all 8 built-in modes and the PlanEdit override: - Build / AddressReviews / Review / IncrementalReview / Plan / Fix / ResolveConflicts / Task: inserts `1. **task list**: create your task list for this run as your first action.` and renumbers existing steps. - action/mcp/selectMode.ts: same insertion in the PlanEdit override checklist. - All internal step cross-references shifted +1 (`step 5` → `step 6`, `skip steps 3–4` → `skip steps 4–5`, etc.) across Review, IncrementalReview, and ResolveConflicts modes. One code-comment reference in IncrementalReview's preamble updated to match. Complements #664 (live progress streaming): streaming guarantees the user sees *something* regardless of compliance; this PR raises the ceiling on what they see when the agent does comply (clean numbered checklist tracking through the run instead of just the latest assistant message). 488 action tests pass; typecheck, lint, format all clean. * postRun: fix stale 'step 7' reference missed during +1 renumbering |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
8e36f76cfa |
postrun: thread AgentRunContext through the retry loop instead of repackaging (#652)
* postrun: thread AgentRunContext through the retry loop instead of repackaging
drop the per-gate plumbing in `runPostRunRetryLoop`: the loop now receives
`ctx: AgentRunContext` whole and reads `ctx.stopScript` + `ctx.toolState.*`
directly. `getUnsubmittedReview` becomes a pure utility in postRun.ts
instead of a closure shipped over `AgentRunContext`. `AgentRunContext`
loses 4 fields that duplicated `toolState` (`summaryFilePath`,
`summarySeed`, `learningsFilePath`, `getUnsubmittedReview`) and gains
`toolState: ToolState`. both harness call sites collapse from 11 lines to
7; main.ts deletes the inline closure.
`ToolState` and friends move from `action/mcp/server.ts` to
`action/toolState.ts` so non-MCP code (agents, post-run loop) stops
importing run-state types from the MCP server module.
no behavior change. 503/503 tests green.
* toolState: relocate `CommentableLines` to break dep cycle with mcp/review
`action/toolState.ts` was importing `CommentableLines` from
`mcp/review.ts`, which pulled the entire MCP server compile graph (24
files) into any consumer of `ToolState` — including `cf-worker-indexing`
via the `pullfrog/internal` re-export chain through `utils/log.ts` →
`agents/shared.ts` → `toolState.ts`. that exposed a pre-existing TS
error in `mcp/issueEvents.ts` (octokit types resolve differently under
cf-worker's `moduleResolution: bundler`).
move `CommentableLines` (a small `{ RIGHT: Set<number>; LEFT: Set<number> }`
state-shape type) to `toolState.ts` where it's used; re-export from
`mcp/review.ts` for back-compat with test and call-site imports. cuts
cf-worker's mcp/ compile inclusion from 24 files back to 0.
* postRun: drop mock-heavy retry-loop tests; keep pure gate predicate
`runPostRunRetryLoop` and `executeStopHook` were covered by ~560 lines
of mock-heavy regression-gate tests that stubbed `spawn` / `getGitStatus`
and fabricated `AgentRunContext` to drive orchestration paths. per
AGENTS.md ("prefer no test over a mock-heavy test that only catches the
most obvious form of regression") and the empirical track record — the
one real production failure of this code path (#646) was a missing npm
release, not a logic bug a unit test could catch — the value-to-ceremony
ratio is poor. delete them.
keep only the pure predicate: `getUnsubmittedReview(toolState)` is a
decision function whose four input conditions have user-visible
consequences when wrong. 5 assertions, no mocks, no ctx fabrication.
488 tests still pass.
* toolState: import PrepResult from prep/types.ts, not the barrel
same dep-cycle class as the previous CommentableLines fix. importing
PrepResult from prep/index.ts pulled prep/installNodeDependencies.ts
into the Next.js production build's typecheck graph (via
pullfrog/internal → utils/log.ts → agents/shared.ts → toolState.ts →
prep/index.ts → installNodeDependencies.ts), and Next.js's stricter
NODE_ENV-required ProcessEnv shape rejected an existing
`env: { PATH: ... }` literal.
prep/types.ts is a leaf module with zero imports — re-routing the type
import severs the chain. Vercel preview deploy goes from Error → Ready;
preview-sync stops racing the deploy.
|
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
ef394277c1 |
review: synthesize [!NOTE] informational tier with #644 alert judiciousness — 4-callout visual ladder + approved Fix-gate (#653)
* review: NOTE-tier callout + `actionable` flag to suppress Fix buttons
Adds an `actionable` parameter to the `create_pull_request_review` tool
(defaults true) so the agent can opt out of the Fix-it/Fix-all/Fix-👍s
footer affordance on informational reviews. Threaded through
`createAndSubmitWithFooter` so the buttons are omitted when
`actionable: false`.
Updates `Review` and `IncrementalReview` mode prompts with a 4th tier:
`> [!NOTE]` + `actionable: false` for mergeable, FYI-style observations
(prior feedback addressed cleanly, minor stale doc reference, etc.).
Calibration note: `[!IMPORTANT]`/`[!CAUTION]` are reserved for findings
that warrant code changes, because that's what trains users to click
Fix. `[!NOTE]` reviews must not carry inline comments — if a point is
concrete enough to anchor to a line, upgrade the whole review tier.
* review: drop redundant `actionable` flag, key Fix buttons off `approved`
`approved` already encodes "this PR is mergeable, nothing for the Fix
button to act on" — `actionable` was a second flag carrying the same
signal. Drop it from the tool schema and `FooterOpts`; the footer gate
stays `if (!opts.approved)` (unchanged from pre-PR behavior, with a new
comment documenting the UX rationale).
NOTE-tier reviews now use `approved: true` + `> [!NOTE]` body instead of
`approved: false` + `actionable: false`. For repos with
`prApproveEnabled: false`, the runtime already downgrades APPROVE to
COMMENT, so the GitHub-side shape is identical to the prior design.
* review: address Pullfrog feedback — drop ambiguous parenthetical + update postRun nudge
- Review-mode calibration: drop the "(or no callout at all)" parenthetical
that didn't map cleanly to a bullet; replace with explicit "both the
`[!NOTE]` tier and the 'no actionable issues' tier below use approved:
true" so the bullet-list anchor is obvious.
- `buildUnsubmittedReviewPrompt` (Review mode): the fallback nudge for
unsubmitted reviews now defers to the mode prompt's tier matrix and
acknowledges that `> [!NOTE]` informational reviews submit with
`approved: true` alongside the canonical "No new issues found." path.
Previously the nudge only described the pre-NOTE binary world.
|
||
|
David Blass
|
10590993f4 |
checkout_pr: retry missing pull/N/head ref with PR-state guard (#627)
* checkout_pr: retry missing pull/N/head ref with PR-state guard Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * checkout_pr tests: satisfy ToolState required fields Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * checkout_pr: tighten retry-helper semantics (anneal round 1) Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * checkout_pr: use retry util, drop retry tests * Update action/mcp/checkout.ts Co-authored-by: pullfrog[bot] <226033991+pullfrog[bot]@users.noreply.github.com> --------- Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: pullfrog[bot] <226033991+pullfrog[bot]@users.noreply.github.com> |
||
|
David Blass
|
10aeaf8c11 |
action: dedupe identical reply_to_review_comment calls within a session (#623)
* action: dedupe identical reply_to_review_comment calls within a session PR #610 reproduced a Kimi K2 stutter where the agent's tool_use surface showed one `pullfrog_reply_to_review_comment` call but GitHub recorded two byte-identical POSTs 3s apart, leaving a duplicate response on `action/mcp/review.ts:14`. Add `duplicateReplyDecision` (mirrors `duplicateReviewDecision`) and track per-session replies on `ToolState.reviewReplies`, keyed by parent `comment_id` + `bodyWithFooter`. Identical re-emissions short circuit with `{ skipped: true, reason }` instead of POSTing again. Body-keyed (not just id-keyed) so legitimate follow-up replies with different content still go through. Tighten `AddressReviews` step 5 to say *exactly once per comment* and note that the runtime dedupes identical bodies, so the agent has both prompt-level guidance and a server-side guarantee. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * address review: drop stale file ref in dedupe comment; soften tool description * remove comment.test.ts --------- Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: pullfrog[bot] <226033991+pullfrog[bot]@users.noreply.github.com> |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
85d25a6fe6 |
post-run gate: fail review-mode runs that don't submit a review or progress (#638)
* post-run gate: fail the run when review mode finishes without a review or progress
review-mode runs that ended in a text-only assistant turn ("now I have enough
to draft the review...") were silently swallowed: the progress comment was
deleted by stranded-comment cleanup and no review appeared on the PR. user-
visible result was identical to "the agent never ran." caught in
https://github.com/pullfrog/app/actions/runs/25583698781.
new post-run gate alongside stopHook / dirtyTree / summaryStale: derived
inline from toolState (selectedMode in {Review, IncrementalReview} && !review
&& !finalSummaryWritten && hadProgressComment) — no parallel toolState flag.
when it fires, the resume prompt nudges the agent to call either
create_pull_request_review or report_progress; persistent failure after
MAX_POST_RUN_RETRIES surfaces as AgentResult.error.
also: when the post-run loop returns success=false, write the error to the
progress comment before the stranded-comment cleanup runs, and skip the
delete in that case. previously a !success run from the loop would lose the
error message into the void.
IncrementalReview's trivial-skip branch now calls report_progress with a
brief "no review warranted" note instead of exiting silently — keeps the
contract symmetric with the gate and gives the user a visible signal even
on no-op review runs.
documents the literal-record design rule on the ToolState interface so
future fields don't drift back into derived/absence-encoding state.
* review feedback: mode-aware nudge, gate-error preservation, prompt order
addresses three findings from the auto-review on this PR:
1. Review mode nudge no longer offers `report_progress` as an exit. Review
mode's contract (modes.ts step 5) forbids it; the gate previously sent
contradictory copy. IncrementalReview's nudge still offers both since
its trivial-skip path legitimately allows `report_progress`.
2. `writeJobSummary` is now wrapped in try/catch on the success-path
cleanup. without this, a throw there jumped to the outer catch and
overwrote the gate's failure message in the progress comment with the
(less actionable) writeJobSummary error — restoring exactly the
invisible-failure UX this PR fixes. step-summary writes are
informational; let them fail silently.
3. `buildPostRunPrompt` reorders gates to match the terminal hard-fail
order: `stopHook` → `unsubmittedReview` → `dirtyTree` → `summaryStale`.
when both hard-fail gates co-fire (rare in review modes), the prompt's
emphasis now matches the user-visible failure message.
new test asserts the IncrementalReview nudge offers both exits while the
Review nudge offers only `create_pull_request_review`. e2e validation
already passed against pullfrog/preview-638-review-stop-hook PR #1
(gate fired once; agent recovered on second turn).
* mode-aware terminal error copy
second auto-review caught a residual contradiction: the terminal hard-fail
error string reported "create_pull_request_review or report_progress" for
both modes, even though the new mode-aware nudge tells Review-mode agents
"Review mode does not have a no-submit exit". the error message now mirrors
the nudge — Review names only `create_pull_request_review`,
IncrementalReview lists both. additional Review-mode hard-fail test asserts
the absence of `report_progress` in the error.
|
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
d6de1c369a |
learnings: edit-in-place tmpfile (drop update_learnings tool) (#635)
* learnings: edit-in-place tmpfile (drop update_learnings tool)
learnings now follow the PR-summary file pattern: server seeds
`pullfrog-learnings.md` from `Repo.learnings` at startup, agent reads
it as part of context, may edit in place during the post-run reflection
turn, server reads back at end-of-run and PATCHes if changed.
motivation: `update_learnings` required the agent to pass the FULL
merged list as a string parameter — an output-token tax that grew
linearly with the learnings size, and a constant prompt-context
expansion since the contents were also inlined into the LEARNINGS
section. for repos with mature learnings the prompt was getting
visibly noisy in CI logs.
key changes:
- new `action/utils/learnings.ts` (seed/read helpers + 10k cap)
- `main.ts`: always seed; `persistLearnings` mirrors `persistSummary`
(success path, error path, exit-signal handler, idempotent guard,
byte-trim equality skip); forwards `model` for `LearningsRevision.model`
- `LEARNINGS` prompt section now contains only the file path + a
one-line "read it" instruction (no contents inlined)
- `update_learnings` MCP tool deleted; `action/mcp/learnings.ts` removed
- reflection turn (`buildLearningsReflectionPrompt`) reframed around
file editing with explicit prune-stale + leave-alone-if-nothing-new
framing
- `learningsStep` removed from every mode checklist — surface lives only
in the LEARNINGS prompt section + the reflection turn now
* learnings: harden seed step + refresh stale docs (review feedback)
Three findings from PR review, all implemented:
1. wrap learnings seed in best-effort try/catch (action/main.ts) —
the always-on seed block ran unconditionally and an unwrapped
`seedLearningsFile` (mkdir + writeFile) failure (ENOSPC, EACCES,
hostile sandbox) would unwind into the outer main() catch and flip
an otherwise-successful run to "❌ Pullfrog failed" before the
agent even started. asymmetric with `persistLearnings`'s own
best-effort contract. wrap and log on failure; downstream
consumers (`persistLearnings`, agent harnesses, `resolveInstructions`)
already handle `learningsFilePath: undefined` cleanly.
2. refresh wiki/main.md — `resolveInstructions` parameter renamed
from `learnings` to `learningsFilePath` in this PR; the data-flow
diagram and the resolver dependency table both still showed the
pre-refactor signature.
3. drop deleted `learnings.ts` from ROADMAP.md + RESEARCH.md
"missing MCP tool tests" bullets — `action/mcp/learnings.ts` was
removed in this PR; the bullets are otherwise still accurate.
|
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
2e6c01670e |
mcp: log artifact id after every github write (#633)
makes debugging easier by emitting a single `» <verb> <kind> <id>` line after every successful GitHub write (and upload) the agent performs via the Pullfrog MCP, mirroring the chevron convention used elsewhere. |
||
|
pullfrog[bot]
|
851e49e2d7 |
action: retry transient GitHub 422 "internal error" on review submission (#610)
* action: retry transient GitHub 422 "internal error" on review submission
GitHub sometimes 422s POST /pulls/{n}/reviews with body
"An internal error occurred, please try again." — a server-side hiccup
that the existing 422 handler framed with the generic
"likely causes (1)(2)(3)" prompt listing affected comments. the agent
dutifully refetched the diff, dropped comments, and resubmitted, hitting
the same transient error on a shifting affected-comments list until
GitHub accepted. some runs logged 8+ spurious retries with ~11 minutes
of wall-clock, dropping valid inline comments along the way.
detect the transient body explicitly, retry in-tool twice with 1s/3s
backoff, and surface a distinct error on exhaustion that tells the agent
this is a GitHub-side issue — do not modify inline comments, wait and
retry or fall back to a body-only review. closes #584.
* action: use retry util for transient review 422, drop isTransientReviewError tests
---------
Co-authored-by: pullfrog[bot] <226033991+pullfrog[bot]@users.noreply.github.com>
|
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
e4e93ea6d3 |
PR summary as agent-edited tmpfile snapshot (#568)
* PR summary as agent-edited tmpfile snapshot Replaces the comment-based PR summary path (and the in-progress update_pr_summary tool from #534) with a snapshot file the agent edits in place during Review / IncrementalReview / pr-summary Task runs. The server seeds the tmpfile with the previous snapshot (incremental) or a stable scaffold (first run), exposes the path via select_mode, and reads it back at end-of-run to persist to WorkflowRun.summarySnapshot and (when the prSummaryComment toggle is on) splice into the PR description body. Why a tmpfile rather than a tool call: incremental snapshot edits are output-token-cheap when the agent uses native file-editing tools, and range-diff cleanly across runs because section headings are stable. The agent never has to regurgitate the full snapshot to update it. Gating: snapshot generation is opt-in via either prSummaryComment="enabled" (splice into PR body) or prReReview="enabled" (snapshot feeds future incremental review runs as context). Users who disable both pay nothing end-to-end — no seeding, DB write, or body splice. Behavior changes: - Drop the Summarize mode and the Summary comment type entirely; the rolling summary is no longer a separate run shape. - pull_request_synchronize with re-review off and summary on still dispatches a silent pr-summary Task, but it edits the snapshot file instead of posting a fresh comment. - /api/repo/.../pr/.../summary-comment now returns { snapshot: string | null } from the DB instead of fetching a comment via GraphQL. URL kept stable so deployed older actions degrade gracefully. - summaryCommentNodeId is retained on WorkflowRun for legacy data and a future backfill of pre-snapshot comment-based summaries. Supersedes #534. The commit-tool/sub-agent direction in that PR is abandoned in favor of this file-based shape. * address review pass #1: synchronize fallback, splice idempotency, docs * address review pass #2: in-flight skip should not race summary fallback * address review pass #3: signal-handler flush, doc clarifications * address review pass #4: in-flight persist promise + bounded body-splice timeout * address review pass #5: defensive catch on persist worker, doc nit * add summary-stale post-run gate When generateSummary is set, we capture the bytes of the seeded snapshot file and pass them to the agent's post-run loop alongside the file path. After each agent attempt, the loop diffs the current file against the seed; if they're byte-identical the agent never touched it, and we nudge once via a resume turn (similar to the dirty-tree gate, but soft and fire-once so smaller models that legitimately decide no edit is warranted don't burn the retry budget). Mostly defends against forgetful smaller models on the Review path — their mode prompt asks them to edit the snapshot file, but the multi-step instruction can fall through when the diff is large. * trigger: retry vercel preview build * fix(action): drop unused re-export that pulled node:fs/promises into next bundle action/internal/index.ts was re-exporting DEFAULT_PR_SUMMARY_INSTRUCTIONS from action/utils/prSummary.ts, but nothing in the next.js app imports it. prSummary.ts uses node:fs/promises, and pullfrog/internal is aliased into the next bundle by next.config.ts, which made turbopack try to resolve node:fs/promises in client chunks and fail with: the chunking context (unknown) does not support external modules (request: node:fs/promises) drop the re-export — selectMode.ts (the only real consumer) already imports it directly from action/utils/prSummary.ts. * firewall PR summary snapshot from user instructions; resurrect rich format for Review The agent-internal snapshot (the markdown file the agent edits in place across runs) is exclusively durable context for future agent runs — user-supplied summarization instructions warp it and degrade that context. Drop the prSummaryCommentInstructions read path end-to-end: - handleWebhook: stop reading prSummaryCommentInstructions, stop passing prSummaryInstructions through dispatch options - action payload + ToolState + selectMode addendum: drop the instructions appendix; the snapshot prompt is fixed, not user-shaped - TriggersSettings: drop the InstructionsEditor for prSummaryCommentInstructions - prSummary.ts: reframe DEFAULT_PR_SUMMARY_INSTRUCTIONS as agent-targeted (durable context, not human-facing prose) Prisma columns (prSummaryComment, prSummaryCommentInstructions) and the matching zod schema entry stay for graceful retreat. Separately, resurrect PR_SUMMARY_FORMAT (deleted along with the Summarize mode in the original PR) and wire it into Review mode only. Initial PR reviews now include a structured summary section in the review body using the rich format (TL;DR, key changes, ## sections with before/after, file-link trails). IncrementalReview keeps its existing terser bullet-list shape since re-review bodies are deltas, not introductions. The user-facing review summary and the agent-internal snapshot are deliberately separate artifacts with separate prompts and zero shared content. * address review comments: prompt self-consistency + stale-doc cleanup PR 568 self-review (4232488109) flagged a self-contradiction the firewall commit introduced and three stale doc references that survived. - action/modes.ts: Review-mode step 2's trivial-PR shortcut said `submit "Reviewed — no issues found." per step 5`, but step 5's rewrite removed exactly that preamble. Aligned both: trivial PRs and no-actionable-issues PRs now produce a body that opens with "No new issues found." followed by the PR summary, so the user gets the headline up front and still sees what was reviewed. - docs/pr-reviews.mdx: dropped the "customize the summary style with Summary instructions in the console" sentence (the editor was removed in the firewall commit). Replaced with a note that the snapshot uses Pullfrog's built-in format and is not user-customizable. - wiki/prompt.md, wiki/modes.md: rewrote the snapshot-prompt entries to reflect the firewall — DEFAULT_PR_SUMMARY_INSTRUCTIONS is the entire prompt, prSummaryCommentInstructions is no longer wired in. * drop orphaned prSummaryCommentInstructions column Prod audit (455 repos): 5 non-null rows on a single account, all containing the literal placeholder text from the InstructionsEditor we removed in the firewall commit. No account has an intentional preference set, so silent-ignore (the keep-for-retreat option) costs us nothing meaningful while leaving an orphan column in the schema. Drop it. - prisma/schema.prisma: remove the column - prisma/migrations/20260506000000_drop_pr_summary_comment_instructions: ALTER TABLE ... DROP COLUMN - utils/schemas/triggers.ts: drop the matching zod entry * drop body splicing; snapshot is internal-only User-visible PR summarization continues to ship in Review and IncrementalReview review bodies (which already render PR_SUMMARY_FORMAT and "Reviewed changes" respectively). The snapshot tmpfile is now purely durable cross-run agent context — seed, edit-in-place, save to DB, feed the next run. Massive simplification: the body splice mechanics, the two-toggle gating matrix, the summaryHandlingCovered race tracking, and the synchronize summary-only Task fallback all go away. Code: - prSummary.ts: drop splice/strip/marker code (`splicePrSummary`, `stripExistingSummaryBlock`, `buildSummaryBlock`, `extractPrSummary`, PULLFROG_SUMMARY_START/END). keep scaffold, instructions, seed/read. - main.ts: rename persistAndPostSummary -> persistSummary; collapse to a single DB PATCH. drop pulls.get/pulls.update, drop AbortSignal timeout, drop in-flight promise machinery, drop prSummaryToBody plumbing. - ToolState: add summarySeed (replaces local var in main.ts so persist can compare). drop prSummaryToBody and summaryPersistInFlight. - persistSummary now compares against the seed and skips the DB write with a warning when unchanged — saving the seed verbatim is either a no-op or persists the placeholder scaffold, neither useful. - postRun.ts: when summary-stale is the only failing gate and the resume turn itself fails, restore the pre-resume successful result and break. symmetric with the existing reflection-failure preservation. summary-stale can no longer flip a successful run to failed. Webhook: - pull_request_opened: generateSummary follows prReReview only (the snapshot has no consumer when re-review is off). - pull_request_synchronize: collapses to "if prReReview enabled, dispatch IncrementalReview". the summaryHandlingCovered flag, the same-SHA/in-flight coordination it was protecting, and the summary-only Task fallback all delete cleanly. UI / config: - drop SummarizePRsTrigger (the toggle gated body splice; with that gone it has no behavior). drop sidebar entry, console import, Text icon import. - drop prSummaryComment from triggers zod schema, prisma schema, preview settings script. Migration: squash the two existing migrations into one timestamped 20260507000000_pr_summary_snapshot covering all three column changes (add summarySnapshot on workflow_runs, drop prSummaryCommentInstructions and prSummaryComment on repos). repo convention is one migration per PR. Action: bump 0.0.203 -> 0.0.205 (payload contract changed: prSummaryToBody removed; main is at 0.0.204). Out-of-diff cleanup: - review.ts:190 + review.test.ts:651 — "Reviewed — no issues found." -> "No new issues found." to match the canonical body in modes.ts. Verified: pnpm typecheck clean, pnpm lint clean, postRun + review tests pass, dev DB reset against production and the squashed migration applied cleanly (summarySnapshot present, prSummaryComment / prSummaryCommentInstructions both gone). * re-orient snapshot toward functional summary; drop prior-review-feedback section Empirical audit on preview-568 PR #5 showed the snapshot IS load-bearing for the orchestrator: lens-dispatch prompts on incremental runs carried forward context from the snapshot's risk register (e.g. "the JSDoc explicitly scopes to code points — do not flag grapheme-cluster issues" on the surrogate-pair fix run, "consistency with native padStart" on the padStart-added run). The orchestrator was reading the snapshot, reasoning about it, and using it to anti-prime / focus subagents — exactly the high-leverage path. My earlier "snapshot is write-only" claim was wrong. The shape, however, was steering it toward review-history-log instead of functional summary. This commit re-orients: - prSummary.ts: replace the four-section scaffold (~580 chars of placeholder italics under "What this PR does / Key changes / Risk / Reviewed in prior runs") with a minimal seed (~150 chars: just a header + a one-line comment about what the file is for). different PRs warrant different organization; forcing a refactor and a feature into the same template is procrustean. minimal seed also makes the unchanged-from-seed gate in persistSummary more sensitive. - selectMode.ts addendum: rewrite around three principles. (1) the snapshot is a FUNCTIONAL summary of what the PR does and the risks it carries, not a chronological review log — commit history can already be reconstructed from list_pull_request_reviews. (2) the orchestrator should USE the snapshot during triage and dispatch — concrete example given of carrying snapshot context into subagent lens prompts. (3) structure is the agent's call; stable headings make snapshots range-diff cleanly when they fit, but riff when they don't. - modes.ts IncrementalReview: drop the "Prior review feedback" checklist from the user-facing review body (step 6b gone, step 7 ELSE IFs cleaned up). It duplicated content that's already covered by the Reviewed-changes bullets and tracked durably in the snapshot for the next agent run; in the user-facing body it was noise. step 3 still fetches prior reviews but its role is now just filtering aggregation in step 5, not rendering. - AGENTS.md: codify "no follow-ups" rule. when an issue is identified during code review, fix it in this PR — PR scope does not constrain quality. follow-up TODOs are forbidden as a substitute for doing the work now. Empirical evidence supporting the re-orientation: - Run 25568912293 (PR#5 incr1, surrogate-pair fix): orchestrator's correctness lens dispatch said "Do NOT flag grapheme-cluster issues — the JSDoc scopes to code points." The grapheme-cluster framing was not in the diff; it was downstream of the snapshot's prior risk-section framing of truncate's contract. Snapshot influencing dispatch. - Run 25569054779 (PR#5 incr2, padStart added): orchestrator's correctness lens dispatch enumerated edge cases including "consistency with native String.prototype.padStart contract" and "fill = multi-code-point string (e.g. emoji)". Both threads carried over from the snapshot's prior truncate code-point-vs-code-unit discussion. Snapshot informing the shape of what was looked for. The cost of maintaining the snapshot (~800 tokens, ~$0.005/run) is trivially affordable when it materially improves orchestrator triage on the 1-5 lenses dispatched per review. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
f87e0f878c |
action: minimize pullfrog.yml permissions and drop actions:read (#594)
* action: minimize pullfrog.yml permissions and drop actions:read
The recommended pullfrog.yml workflow asked for a permissions block that's
broader than what the action actually uses with the workflow GITHUB_TOKEN —
all real work (git push, PR comments, reviews) goes through installation
tokens that the action mints via OIDC. Customer security scanners flagged
the workflow-level block as too permissive.
- Move permissions to the job level and reduce to id-token: write,
pull-requests: write, issues: write. contents:read is the implicit default
and covers actions/checkout; contents:write, checks:read are unused by
any GITHUB_TOKEN consumer; actions:read was only used by post-cleanup's
listJobsForWorkflowRun call.
- Replace listJobsForWorkflowRun with a SIGTERM/SIGINT handler in main.ts
that calls core.saveState("cancelled", "true"); post-cleanup reads it
back via core.getState. Same cancel-vs-failure UX, no extra scope needed.
- Sync the docs (headless-action, getting-started, action/README) and the
two dogfood pullfrog.yml workflows to the new minimal block. Update the
post-cleanup wiki to describe the saveState approach.
* action: drop pull-requests/issues from required workflow scopes
Switch postCleanup.ts to mint its own short-lived installation token via OIDC
(acquireNewToken with issues:write + pull_requests:write) instead of using the
workflow GITHUB_TOKEN. Same comment-update behavior, but the workflow no longer
needs those scopes — the only permissions Pullfrog ever asks for are id-token:write
(OIDC exchange) and contents:read (actions/checkout).
Also fixes a bug from the previous commit: setting an explicit permissions block
drops every unlisted scope to none (with metadata as the only exception), so
omitting contents would have broken actions/checkout. Restored at both workflow
and job level.
* action: scope id-token:write to pullfrog job, not workflow level
id-token:write is the powerful one — it lets a job mint OIDC tokens that can
be exchanged for cloud credentials or our installation tokens. Keeping it at
workflow level means any future job added to this file silently inherits it.
Move it to the job level where it's actually used; leave only contents:read
at workflow level as a safe baseline for any future jobs.
* action: move stuck-comment cleanup server-side, drop write perms entirely
The action's post-cleanup step lived inside the runner and used the workflow
GITHUB_TOKEN to update the "Leaping into action…" progress comment when a run
failed/cancelled, requiring pull-requests:write + issues:write at the workflow
level. Move that responsibility to the workflow_run.completed webhook handler:
it already has installation-token access via the GitHub App, runs server-side
(no Pullfrog API dependency loop on failure), and lets us drop both write perms.
Recommended workflow permissions block is now truly minimal:
permissions:
contents: read
jobs:
pullfrog:
permissions:
id-token: write
contents: read
Server side
- handleWorkflowRunCompleted: when conclusion != "success" and the WorkflowRun
has progressCommentId, mint installation octokit and update the stuck comment
in place. Try issues.getComment first, fall back to pulls.getReviewComment on
404 (we don't store comment type — one wasted GET on the rarer review case).
- Reuses buildPullfrogFooter and updateProgressComment from pullfrog/internal,
matching the wording the action used to write client-side.
Client side
- Delete action/utils/postCleanup.ts and action/post.ts.
- Remove post: + post-if: from action/action.yml.
- Drop runPostCleanup wiring from action/commands/gha.ts and action/play.ts.
- Remove the SIGTERM/saveState handler I added in main.ts in the previous commit
(no longer needed; cancel/fail signal comes from the webhook hook payload).
Plumbing
- Extract isLeapingIntoActionCommentBody into action/utils/leapingComment.ts so
the predicate can be re-exported via pullfrog/internal without dragging the
MCP server's transitive type graph into the Next.js app's typecheck.
- mcp/comment.ts re-exports from the new location for backward compat.
Wiki
- Delete wiki/post-cleanup.md (obsolete; cleanup is now a one-liner branch in
the workflow_run webhook handler).
* chore: ignore .worktrees in biome config
Recently-added pnpm worktree feature creates nested git worktrees under
.worktrees/, each with their own biome.jsonc declaring root. Biome's
recursive scan trips on the nested config and fails pnpm lint. Excluding
the directory matches the existing .gitignore entry.
* fix: address PR #594 review findings
Two real bugs caught by code review:
1. handleWorkflowRunWebhook.ts:323 — drop the /m flag on the stuck-comment
detection regex. With /m, ^ matches any line start, so any finalized
progress comment that embeds a task list (report_progress writes
`- [x]`/`- [ ]` lines via todoTracking.ts) would be flagged as "stuck"
and silently overwritten with the "This run croaked" boilerplate
whenever the workflow concluded non-success after the agent's final
summary already landed. Restores the body-start anchoring the original
in-process postCleanup.ts:90 had.
2. action/scripts/check-entrypoint-imports.ts — drop ../post.ts from the
esbuild entry-point list (the file was deleted in aa43b9af). The
`pnpm check:entrypoints` step in test.yml would have failed on every
run with an unresolvable-entry-point error.
Plus three small follow-ups:
- main.ts:580 — comment said "post-cleanup has its own verify-retry loop"
but post-cleanup is gone. Updated to describe the new server-side path.
- mcp/comment.ts:443 — comment said "so post script doesn't think the run
failed". Updated to describe the actual current consumers of wasUpdated.
- commands/gha.ts:84 — `--post` help text said "run post-cleanup flow" but
with the post-cleanup path removed, --post is only valid alongside the
`token` subcommand for installation-token revocation. Updated wording.
* fix(action): scope --post help text to gha token subcommand
Root gha help text was documenting --post, but --post only makes sense
paired with the token subcommand (it's how the post step revokes the
installation token previously acquired in the main step). Move it to a
dedicated gha token help section and add a parser layer that rejects
--post on the bare gha command.
$ pullfrog gha --help
usage: pullfrog gha [subcommand]
...
options:
-h, --help show help
$ pullfrog gha token --help
usage: pullfrog gha token [--post]
...
options:
-h, --help show help
--post revoke the previously-acquired token (post-step usage only)
* webhook: artifact-aware cleanup of stranded leaping comments on success
Previously the workflow_run.completed cleanup only handled non-success
conclusions. Extend it to also catch the rare case where a successful
run leaves a "Leaping into action…" comment stuck (in-process cleanup at
action/main.ts:723 normally handles this, but can be skipped on SIGKILL,
runner host crash, or any exit path that bypasses main()'s finally block).
New behavior in cleanupStuckProgressComment:
- cancelled → update with "cancelled 🛑" body (unchanged)
- failure (other) → update with "croaked 😵" body (unchanged)
- success + artifact recorded → delete the comment (the artifact is the
user-facing surface; the leaping comment
is just stale UI noise at this point)
- success + no artifact recorded → delete the comment AND alert
team@pullfrog.com via emailAlert
The "success + no artifact" path is "should never happen" territory: the
run claims success but produced no review, PR, issue, plan, or summary
comment. The team alert helps us catch in-process cleanup regressions or
artifact-tracking gaps. hasRecordedArtifact reads {review,pr,issue,
planComment,summaryComment}NodeId off the WorkflowRun row to make the call.
* webhook: narrow stuck-comment detection to leaping prefix only
Drop the stranded-todo-pattern branch from cleanupStuckProgressComment.
The leaping prefix is highly specific and impossible to confuse with a
legitimate summary; a leading todo line is not — the agent's
error-reporting paths can produce useful explanatory comments whose
body leads with a checklist (e.g. "here's what I was working on" + the
incomplete todo list), and we don't want to silently overwrite those
with the generic "croaked" boilerplate.
In-process cleanup at action/main.ts:723 still handles the stranded-todo
case in the common path (gated on !finalSummaryWritten with full access
to the in-memory tool state). Missing the rare runner-died-mid-todo case
server-side is a worthwhile trade vs. the false-positive risk on real
explanatory comments.
|
||
|
pullfrog[bot]
|
366af55f19 |
fix(action): sweep stale .git/*.lock and deepen-retry shallow git_fetch (#564) (#578)
- checkoutPrBranch now removes .git/shallow.lock, .git/index.lock, and .git/objects/maintenance.lock when older than 30s before the first fetch. prior runs that crashed mid-fetch left these behind on self-hosted runners, causing checkout_pr to abort with `Unable to create '.git/shallow.lock': File exists` until the agent shelled out to rm -f. - GitFetchTool catches `Could not read <sha>` and `remote did not send all necessary objects` on shallow clones and retries once with --deepen=1000 instead of bouncing the failure back to the agent. agents previously had to fall back to checking out FETCH_HEAD, losing branch context. Co-authored-by: pullfrog[bot] <226033991+pullfrog[bot]@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: David Blass <david@arktype.io> |
||
|
pullfrog[bot]
|
4c1413d925 |
fix(action): flip wasUpdated on substantive MCP write tools (#563) (#577)
* fix(action): flip wasUpdated on substantive MCP write tools (#563) Review/Respond/etc. agents that submit a `create_pull_request_review`, `create_issue_comment`, or `update_pull_request_body` and exit without calling `report_progress` were being marked as workflow failures by the strict completion check in handleAgentResult. Extend the set of tools that flip toolState.wasUpdated so a substantive user-visible artifact satisfies the check. The isReviewMode bypass is retained for IncrementalReview's non-substantive path. Flag is set BEFORE patchWorkflowRunFields / deleteProgressComment in each tool so a best-effort cleanup failure does not undo the signal. * fix(action): use finalSummaryWritten for stranded progress cleanup The stranded-progress-comment cleanup at the end of main() previously fired only when toolState.wasUpdated was false (or the tracker was the last writer). With wasUpdated now set by additional MCP write tools (create_issue_comment, update_pull_request_body), an agent that produced a substantive artifact via one of those tools and skipped report_progress would leave the placeholder "Leaping into action" comment intact — the post-script then converted it into an error message on a successful run. Key the cleanup off finalSummaryWritten instead. That flag is only set when report_progress actually wrote the progress comment, so it cleanly distinguishes "comment is finalized" from "agent did other work but never touched the progress comment". * refactor(mcp): extract markSubstantiveArtifact() helper replaces 4 inline `ctx.toolState.wasUpdated = true` flips in CreateCommentTool, UpdatePullRequestBodyTool, and CreatePullRequestReviewTool with a single helper in mcp/server.ts. JSDoc on the helper documents the contract (call BEFORE downstream patch/cleanup; gates the strict completion check and stranded-comment cleanup) so future MCP write tool authors only need to grep for one symbol. no behavioral change. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * fix(mcp): only flip finalSummaryWritten after non-skipped write Previously the flag was set unconditionally on any non-plan call, including paths where reportProgress skipped (silent events, deleted comment, no issue/PR target). The cleanup check in main.ts is safeguarded by toolState.progressComment so the bug doesn't manifest today, but aligning the flag with actual writes matches the wasUpdated pattern and the design intent in the cleanup plan. * refactor(mcp): inline markSubstantiveArtifact helper --------- Co-authored-by: pullfrog[bot] <226033991+pullfrog[bot]@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: David Blass <david@arktype.io> Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> |
||
|
pullfrog[bot]
|
6db4a6d02e |
fix(mcp): preserve coveragePreflightRan across checkout_pr refreshes (#576)
checkout_pr unconditionally rebuilds ctx.toolState.diffCoverage via createDiffCoverageState, which initialised coveragePreflightRan to false. a second checkout_pr therefore reset the "one-time nudge per review session" guarantee in runDiffCoveragePreflight, and the next create_pull_request_review threw the diff-coverage pre-flight error again — even after the agent had already gone through the read-and-resubmit dance once. createDiffCoverageState now accepts an optional previous state and carries forward coveragePreflightRan. coveredRanges are intentionally not carried because their line numbers are tied to the previous diff's content (especially under incremental diffs). closes #566 Co-authored-by: pullfrog[bot] <226033991+pullfrog[bot]@users.noreply.github.com> Co-authored-by: David Blass <david@arktype.io> |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
560e27bda5 |
refactor progress comments into a bundled type + helper module (#567)
* refactor progress comments into a single bundled type + helper module
introduce ProgressComment ({ id, type: "issue" | "review" }) as the canonical handle for
the GitHub comment a run uses to report progress, and route every read/update/delete/create
through a single helper module (action/utils/progressComment.ts). previously every site that
touched the progress comment hardcoded octokit.rest.issues.*Comment, which made adding a
second comment type (review-thread replies) require duplicating the same branch in 6+ places
— the same shape that bit pullfrog/app#445.
new capability: when the address-reviews trigger fires for a one-off review comment, the
"Leaping into action" comment is now posted as a reply in that review thread instead of as
a top-level PR timeline comment. the helper handles failure (e.g. parent comment deleted)
by silently falling back to a top-level issue comment, so the run never loses its progress
surface.
changes:
- action/utils/progressComment.ts (new) — ProgressComment type + getProgressComment,
updateProgressComment, deleteProgressCommentApi, createLeapingProgressComment. uses a
structural Octokit interface to bridge the @octokit/rest version mismatch between the
action package (v22) and the root project (v21).
- action/internal/index.ts — re-export the new types and helpers for cross-boundary use.
- action/external.ts, action/utils/payload.ts — replace progressCommentId: string with
progressComment: { id: string, type: "issue" | "review" } in WriteablePayload + JsonPayload.
wire-format breaking, no legacy fallback (in-flight runs across the deploy lose their
progress comment, fine).
- action/mcp/server.ts — ToolState.progressCommentId becomes
progressComment: ProgressComment | null | undefined (same tristate semantics).
- action/main.ts, action/mcp/comment.ts, action/utils/errorReport.ts,
action/utils/postCleanup.ts — every issues.*Comment call against the progress comment
routes through the helper module. zero hardcoded API branching outside the helper.
- utils/github/triggerWorkflow.ts — drop createLeapingComment + updateCommentToLeaping;
dispatchAndTrackWorkflow gains a resolution chain (existingComment → replyToReviewComment
→ triggeringIssue → none) and an existingComment: ProgressComment param plus
replyToReviewComment: { pullNumber, commentId }.
- utils/webhooks/handleWebhook.ts — dispatch closure threads replyToReviewComment through;
the one-off review comment branch passes it and skips the now-redundant eyes reaction
on the comment we're about to reply to.
- app/trigger/[owner]/[repo]/[number]/page.tsx, utils/github/runActionLocal.ts,
app/api/cli/dispatch/route.ts, app/api/dispatch-workflow/route.ts — call sites updated to
new shape.
no schema or DB column changes. the existing WorkflowRun.progressCommentId column is still
written by id only; type lives only on the in-flight payload, which is sufficient for
runtime since it's the only thing that needs to know which API to call.
* anneal pass 1: fallback visibility + stale doc/comment updates
- progressComment.ts: when reviewReply→issue fallback fires, prepend a [!NOTE] callout
with a permalink back to the original review comment. without this, the parent comment
showed no eyes reaction (deliberately skipped) and no reply, leaving the user with no
signal that anything happened.
- wiki/post-cleanup.md: update progressCommentId references to progressComment, document
the new helper-based dispatch by type.
- wiki/main.md: update initToolState({ progressCommentId }) → ({ progressComment })
in the resolver-chain diagram.
- action/main.ts, action/mcp/review.ts: update two stale comments that referenced the
old field name.
* anneal pass 2: post-cleanup detection through fallback notice + log cleanup
- isLeapingIntoActionCommentBody: strip a leading GFM blockquote/alert before
testing the leaping prefix. without this, the [!NOTE] callout that the
reviewReply→issue fallback prepends would prevent post-cleanup from
recognizing the stuck "Leaping into action..." comment, leaving it permanently
on the PR timeline if the workflow died before any progress update.
- progressComment helper: switch from log.warning (action-flavored, emits a
::warning:: GitHub Actions annotation) to console.warn so the helper doesn't
pollute Vercel logs when invoked from the webhook context.
- triggerWorkflow.ts: drop the duplicate caller-side log on review-reply
failure — the helper already speaks loudly. Reword the catch-branch log to
reflect that it now only fires when both the reply AND the helper's internal
fallback failed.
- progressComment.ts: document that the [!NOTE] fallback notice is overwritten
on the first report_progress call, and explain the trade-off vs persisting
it through the action payload + ToolState.
* debloat: drop the [!NOTE] fallback callout
Reverting two pieces from the prior anneal pass:
- progressComment.ts: drop the [!NOTE] callout that the reviewReply→issue fallback
prepended to the leaping body. It disappeared on the agent's first report_progress
call, which made it half-committed to visibility — worse than either properly
persisting it (real engineering) or leaving the fallback silent (current choice).
The console.warn diagnostic and the workflow-run footer link in the leaping
comment itself give us enough signal for the rare case where both API endpoints
fail at once.
- isLeapingIntoActionCommentBody: revert the leading-blockquote stripping; only
needed to compensate for the [!NOTE] callout.
Keeping: the console.warn-vs-log.warning fix (real cross-runtime concern), the
duplicate-log drop in triggerWorkflow.ts, the wiki updates, and the two stale
source-comment fixes.
* fix: prevent stranded task list overwriting post-cleanup message
When a run is cancelled, the action's todoTracker may have an HTTP write in
flight to GitHub when SIGTERM lands. The action process dies, but the request
data has already left the socket — GitHub processes it and updates the comment
body to the (stale) task list. Meanwhile post-cleanup, running in a separate
process, writes the "This run was cancelled 🛑" message. If the tracker's
in-flight write happens to land *after* post-cleanup's write, the user never
sees the cancellation message.
Two-layer fix:
- Action side: cancel the tracker in the SIGTERM signal handler so no new
debounced writes get scheduled. This shrinks the race window but can't
un-send a request already on the wire.
- Post-cleanup side: after writing, verify the body landed and re-issue if
another write clobbered ours. Loops up to 3× with a 3s settle delay so
delayed in-flight writes from the dying action have time to arrive before
our read-back check decides whether to retry.
* lint: import createLeapingProgressComment from pullfrog/internal in test script
* address bot review findings: reply-target root, version bump, GET error handling
Three real findings from the bot reviews on #567 plus a small DRY pass:
1. handleWebhook reply-target: `newComments[0]` may be a reply, not a
top-level review comment. `getReviewCommentsWithReplies` returns root +
replies for any thread the review touched, and `pull_request_review_id`
filtering only narrows by *which review submitted*, not *root vs reply*.
When a user submits a single reply as their entire review (e.g. replying
to someone else's comment to ping @pullfrog), the reply ID flowed through
to `createReplyForReviewComment`, which 422s on replies-to-replies and
degraded to a top-level issue comment — exactly the polluted-PR-timeline
behavior this PR was built to remove. Walk up `in_reply_to` from the
already-fetched thread data to find the root and reply there instead.
2. action/package.json: bumped 0.0.202 → 0.0.204. main is at 0.0.203 and
our wire format changed; without a bump validateCompatibility can't
surface the mismatch on the deploy boundary, and the merge would have
gone backwards.
3. postCleanup writeAndVerify: distinguish a thrown verify-GET from a
"body got overwritten" mismatch. Treating a transient 5xx/rate-limit GET
the same as a clobber wasted PUT attempts and printed a misleading
"in-flight writes kept clobbering us" warning. We trust our PUT (which
returned 200) and exit instead of amplifying writes against a flaky API.
4. Small DRY: extracted parseProgressComment for the
`{ id: string; type } -> ProgressComment` parse that had drifted across
server.ts and postCleanup.ts.
|
||
|
David Blass
|
ada5584737 |
test(mcp): make checkout/reviewComments tests offline (fixture-driven) (#575)
`mcp/checkout.test.ts` and `mcp/reviewComments.test.ts` previously hit live GitHub on every run via `acquireNewToken()`, requiring `GH_TOKEN` or `GITHUB_APP_ID` + `GITHUB_PRIVATE_KEY` in the env. that made them: - cred-gated — the action runtime filters `_KEY$` / `_TOKEN$` from subprocess env, so the husky pre-push hook (which runs `pnpm -r test`) blocked Pullfrog agents from pushing branches. issues #562, #563, #564, #566 all hit this exact blocker and never got their fixes pushed. - non-deterministic and slow (network round-trips for a snapshot test). both tests are really snapshot tests of pure formatters (`formatFilesWithLineNumbers`, plus `parseFilePatches` / `buildThreadBlocks` / `formatReviewThreads` for review data). the live fetches were just an inefficient way to obtain fixtures. changes: 1. extract a pure `formatReviewData({ review, threads, prFiles, ... })` from `getReviewData` in `mcp/reviewComments.ts`. `getReviewData` becomes thin orchestration: fetch + call formatter. preserves the "skip listFiles when no threads" perf optimization. 2. add `action/mcp/__fixtures__/` with checked-in JSON captures for the three fixture test cases (pullfrog/test-repo#1 listFiles, pullfrog/scratch#49 review 3485940013, pullfrog/scratch#64 review 3531000326). ~14KB total. fixtures store only the fields the formatter reads — volatile fields (sha, blob_url, etc.) are dropped. 3. rewrite both test files to load the fixtures and call the pure formatters directly. snapshot keys updated; snapshot content unchanged (verified by running existing snapshots against the refactored tests). 4. add `action/scripts/refresh-test-fixtures.ts` to re-fetch the fixtures from live GitHub on demand: `node action/scripts/refresh-test-fixtures.ts` (with creds in `.env` or env). re-run when the GitHub API response shape changes and review the snapshot diff. trade-off: a silent change to GitHub's `pulls.listFiles` / `pulls.getReview` / GraphQL `reviewThreads` response shape would no longer break this test on every push. that tradeoff is worth it: shape drift on those endpoints is rare (years between changes), and a dedicated cron that runs the refresh script and opens a PR on diff is a far better signal than a flaky cred-gated pre-push hook. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> |
||
|
David Blass
|
b6e2c61d30 |
fix(push_branch): retry transient push errors and surface full stderr/stdout (#573)
* fix(push_branch): retry transient push errors and surface full stderr/stdout issue #571 motivated three small improvements to `mcp__pullfrog__push_branch`: 1. classify push errors into `concurrent-push` / `transient` / `unknown`. - `concurrent-push` extends the existing `fetch first` / `non-fast-forward` matcher to also catch the server-side `cannot lock ref` form (the case #571 reports). all three route to the same fetch + integrate + retry recovery message; copy now mentions concurrent push as a likely cause. - `transient` covers RPC failed, early EOF, connection reset, dns flake, HTTP 5xx, HTTP/2 stream not closed, and unexpected sideband disconnect. these are retried in-tool with 2s + 5s backoff before surfacing the error. push is idempotent so verbatim retry is safe. - `unknown` (auth/permission/protected-branch/4xx) is rethrown unchanged — retrying these wastes time and noise. 2. surface stdout alongside stderr in `$git` failure messages and include the exit code. previously only `stderr.trim()` was forwarded, which could be empty in rare HTTPS failure modes (the agent on issue #571's run saw a one-line `failed to push some refs` and had nothing to diagnose with). 3. unit tests for the classifier covering all three branches plus the concurrent-push-wins-over-transient ordering. does not introduce auto fetch+rebase+retry inside the tool — that path is blocked under shell=disabled, can leave the working tree mid-conflict, and would create unwanted merge commits. the recovery message keeps the agent in the loop. Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> * fix(push_branch): retry 429, jitter backoff, downgrade retry log to info - treat HTTP 429 (rate-limit / abuse detection) as transient — GitHub occasionally surfaces it on git push, where it is retry-safe unlike 401/403/404 - add ±25% jitter to backoff so concurrent agents hit by the same upstream blip don't retry in lockstep - log retries with log.info instead of log.warning to match retry.ts convention; a successful retry shouldn't leave a yellow GHA annotation behind in the job summary --------- Co-authored-by: Cursor <cursoragent@cursor.com> Co-authored-by: pullfrog[bot] <226033991+pullfrog[bot]@users.noreply.github.com> |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
e58299740d |
Merge pull request #545 from pullfrog/billing
managed billing + stripe v1 |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
8c01ee3251 |
guard against duplicate create_pull_request_review calls in the same session (#553)
the agent occasionally submits twice in one Review-mode run — once with substantive feedback, then again with the canonical "Reviewed — no issues found." body when the prompt's branch logic re-classifies non-blocking observations as "no actionable issues" (see colinhacks/zod#5897). the second submission is always redundant noise on the PR. duplicateReviewDecision short-circuits the second call when toolState.review is already populated for the current checkout sha. legitimate follow-up reviews after new commits still go through because the new-commits-mid-review path advances toolState.checkoutSha past the prior reviewedSha before returning, so the next call sees a different sha and is allowed. |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
8cee07d388 |
move progress-comment cleanup into create_pull_request_review (#551)
* fix: snapshot review state so progress comment cleanup actually fires postReviewCleanup deletes toolState.review as its second statement, so the defense-in-depth `if (toolState.review && progressCommentId)` branch right after never saw a truthy value. This left an orphaned progress comment alongside the submitted review whenever the agent called report_progress despite Review/IncrementalReview mode instructions (seen in the wild on colinhacks/zod#5767). Snapshot the boolean before postReviewCleanup runs. * move progress-comment cleanup into create_pull_request_review The previous commit snapshotted toolState.review to work around postReviewCleanup deleting it before the cleanup branch could read it. That fixed the symptom but kept a fragile design: the rule "review submitted → progress comment is noise" was enforced from the bottom of main.ts via a flag set in one place and consumed in another, with a helper between them that mutated the same flag for unrelated reasons. Move the rule to its natural owner. create_pull_request_review now calls deleteProgressComment immediately after the review is persisted, so the cleanup is atomic with submission. This: - closes the catch-block hole — a review submitted right before a timeout/crash now still cleans up its progress comment. - removes the dead "defense-in-depth" branch in main.ts that was the original bug surface. - relies on the existing progressCommentId=null no-op path in reportProgress to make any later report_progress call a no-op (so the misbehavior path can't re-create the orphan). - only fires for Review/IncrementalReview in practice — those are the only modes that call create_pull_request_review, and both are prompted not to call report_progress. Build/AddressReviews/Plan never reach this code path, so their progress comments remain untouched. Stranded-comment cleanup in main.ts is unchanged and still handles the truly orphaned case (no review, no report_progress). |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
55c95e6f50 |
Fix Node 24 action bootstrap fallback (#556)
* Fix Node 24 action bootstrap fallback Resolve the published CLI launcher through PATH so runners missing a sibling Node 24 npx can still start, and make post cleanup recognize prefixed leaping comments. * Bump Pullfrog action package version Ensure the Node 24 bootstrap and post-cleanup fixes publish to npm and move the v0 action tag. * Walk PATH for corepack and npx in action bootstrap ensureActionDependencies and runPackageCli now resolve corepack/npx through PATH the same way as the npx-via-PATH fix, so Node 24 runner pools missing either sibling can still bootstrap. Also adds a Zod-mirror settings helper for the preview-556 repo and documents the per-PR settings workflow. * log when corepack PATH fallback is used |
||
|
David Blass
|
57bd10d6dd |
run-issues fixes: #5, #11, #12, #15, #16/#25, #20, #21, #22, #31 (#546)
* fix(#15): precompute diff anchors in checkout_pr TOC * test(#15): update TOC snapshot for precomputed diff anchors * chore(tests): skip codex-mini-latest models.dev check + refresh latest-by-provider snapshot * fix(#22): add commitCount and commitLog to checkout_pr return * fix(#21): include PR body in checkout_pr return * fix(#5): force-fetch PR refspec to overwrite stale local branch * fix(#31): rename git tool parameter from subcommand to command * fix(#11): soft-fail post-checkout hook, bump timeout to 10min * fix(#16): strengthen diff file usage guidance Agent was bypassing diffPath and running `git diff` instead. Tighten instructions in `checkout_pr` result and remove the mixed-signal "log, diff" listing in the global Git guidance. `git log` and `git diff --stat` remain allowed for commit-range overview. * fix(#20): drop invalid inline review comments instead of failing review Previously, a single inline comment anchored outside a diff hunk would 422 the entire review submission. Pre-validate comments against the PR file patches via listFiles, drop the invalid ones, and append a note to the review body listing what was skipped. Include the dropped list in the tool response so the agent can retry targeted fixes. * fix(#12): stop MCP server on inner activity kill + filter reconnect noise Inner-activity-kill zombies were burning multi-hour runner time because mcp-proxy's SSE reconnect and provider-error retry lines kept the outer activity timer alive long after the agent subprocess was killed. - Filter [mcp-proxy] / "provider error detected" chunks so they don't count as outer-timer activity. - Add onActivityTimeout callback to spawn + thread through agent runs. - main.ts wires that callback to stop the MCP HTTP server (so reconnects finally fail instead of looping) and arms a 5min safety-net timer that force-rejects the outer timer if the agent promise is still pending. * audit: harden #12 lifecycle + cover #20/#12 with unit tests Bugs found during Ralph audit of the prior run-issues fixes: - main.ts's 5min safety-net setTimeout was never cleared on the happy path; also activityTimeout.stop() didn't null the internal rejectFn, so a late forceReject from the safety-net could still reject a long-resolved promise. Timer now cleared in finally; stop() now disarms forceReject. - mcp server disposal was non-idempotent, so the inner-kill path ran server.stop() twice once the outer `await using` block exited. Made the returned disposer idempotent. Tests: - action/mcp/review.test.ts: 14 tests for commentableLinesForFile (multi-hunk, no-count hunks, no-newline marker, empty) and validateInlineComments (file not in diff, wrong side, out-of-range line and start_line, partitioning batches, default side). - action/utils/activity.test.ts: 6 tests for isActivityNoise covering mcp-proxy lines, provider-error lines, mixed chunks, Buffer input. * audit(#22): cap commitLog at 200 + scope git-diff restriction to PR review - cap git log --oneline at 200 entries so a PR with thousands of commits cannot blow up the MCP tool response; expose commitLogTruncated so callers can warn the agent when the log was clipped - tighten instruction wording so `git diff` / `git diff --cached` remain available for inspecting an agent's own uncommitted changes, while PR review content must still come from diffPath Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#11,#22,#31): surface hook/commit warnings in instructions + polish git tool - append hookWarning + commitLogTruncated advisories to checkout_pr instructions so the agent actually sees the warning inline, not just as a field it may skip - fix stale 'subcommand' wording in git tool redirect for `pull` and in the `command` parameter description; the MCP parameter is named `command` now, and that's what the agent binds to Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * fix(#20): reassign params.comments even when all inline comments dropped if every inline comment fails pre-validation, the earlier guard skipped reassigning params.comments, so the submission still carried the bad comments and GitHub 422'd on the whole review. always reassign to validation.valid so the downstream 'nothing left to post' skip fires and an otherwise-empty review is no-oped cleanly. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#22): degrade gracefully when base ref isn't resolvable checkout_pr used to assume \`origin/<base>\` is always reachable, but it isn't guaranteed after a shallow fetch that only pulled down the PR head. Failing the whole checkout over metadata we added for ergonomics would be a regression, so wrap the rev-list / log in a try/catch and return empty commit metadata instead. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#12): anchor noise patterns to line start to avoid false positives before this, a line like "agent said: [mcp-proxy] was there" or "context: provider error detected in log" in real agent output would have been treated as noise and failed to reset the outer activity timer. both patterns now anchor at the start of the (optionally debug-timestamped) line, matching only lines mcp-proxy or our own log.info actually emit. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#20): export and unit-test formatDroppedCommentsNote covers single-line `path:N`, multi-line `path:start-end`, and startLine==line fallback so changes to the dropped-comments note format surface in test diffs instead of only in GitHub UI. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#20): cap dropped-comment note to stay under GitHub body limit a pathological run (agent emits hundreds of invalid inline comments on a huge PR and they all get dropped) would push the review body past GitHub's ~65KB limit and fail the whole submission with a body-too-long 422 — the exact all-or-nothing failure #20 was meant to prevent. cap the detail list at 50 entries with a "…and N more" line so the note stays bounded. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#20): distinguish binary/no-patch files in dropped-comment reason previously a comment on a binary file (or pure rename / mode-only change) was dropped with "line X is not inside a diff hunk", which misleads the agent into retrying with different line numbers. call out the no-textual-diff case explicitly so the agent knows to move that feedback to the review body instead. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#11): replace lifecycle timeout string-match with typed sentinel spawn() now rejects with SpawnTimeoutError (code === SPAWN_TIMEOUT_CODE or SPAWN_ACTIVITY_TIMEOUT_CODE) instead of a plain Error. executeLifecycleHook now branches on that code so rewording the error message in subprocess.ts can no longer silently misroute timeouts into the "transient — retry" warning. * audit(#12): route agent hung-vs-failed via typed SpawnTimeoutError claude.ts and opentoad.ts decide between "hung" and "failed" log wording based on the subprocess error. move them off the literal "activity timeout" substring match onto the same SPAWN_ACTIVITY_TIMEOUT_CODE sentinel used by lifecycle.ts so all three call sites agree on the source of truth. * audit(#20): delete leftover pending review when submit fails Why: `createAndSubmitWithFooter` creates a PENDING review first so we can mint Fix-links with the review ID, then submits. If submitReview fails (e.g. 422 from a race where the diff moved between pre-validation and submission), the draft was left on the PR. GitHub only allows one pending review per user, so the agent's retry would then fail with "already has a pending review" — an error the agent has no tools to clean up from. Best-effort cleanup: delete the pending draft on submit failure before re-throwing the original error, so retries start from a clean slate. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#31): point agent to concrete alternative when rebase/bisect blocked Why: in disabled-shell mode, `git rebase` and `git bisect` are blocked as arbitrary-code-execution escape hatches. Previous error messages explained *why* but left the agent without a next step — especially painful right after the `pull` redirect, which suggested "merge or rebase locally." The agent would follow that advice, hit the rebase block, and loop without knowing what to try next. Now: rebase block explicitly says "use 'merge' instead"; bisect block notes that manual bisect is also unavailable through this tool; pull redirect no longer recommends rebase in shell-disabled contexts. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: import security tables into security.test to prevent drift Why: the security tests re-declared AUTH_REQUIRED_REDIRECT, NOSHELL_BLOCKED_SUBCOMMANDS, and NOSHELL_BLOCKED_ARGS inline with hand-copied message strings. When the runtime messages in git.ts were tightened (recent rebase/bisect guidance updates), the test copies drifted and tests validated a stale version of the logic while passing clean. A missing or mistyped entry in git.ts could therefore slip through. Now: export the tables from git.ts and import them into the test file. If a runtime message changes, the tests exercise the new string automatically; if an entry is added or removed, tests covering that command see the change without manual sync. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: widen pending-review cleanup to cover pre-submit throws getApiUrl() (invoked in footer build) can throw if API_URL is misconfigured, which would leak a pending draft between createReview and the previous submitReview try/catch. Move the try/catch to wrap the entire post-create body so any throw routes through deletePendingReview cleanup. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: reject leading-dash refs/branch names to block flag injection git's parseopt accepts options intermixed with positional args, so a ref like "--upload-pack=evil" passed to git_fetch could be parsed as a flag rather than a refspec. Add a narrow rejectIfLeadingDash helper to git_fetch (ref), delete_branch (branchName), and push_branch (branchName). HTTPS remotes ignore --upload-pack server-side, but the hygiene matters for defense in depth (ssh remotes, future code paths). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: validate the resolved branch in push_branch too When branchName is omitted, rev-parse surfaces the current branch name, which could start with '-' if git state was tampered with. Move the leading-dash check to after the branch is resolved so both the explicit and derived paths go through validation. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: cache commentable-lines snapshot at checkout to match review anchor Review comments are anchored to checkoutSha (commit_id), but validation was hitting pulls.listFiles at review time — latest HEAD, not the SHA the agent actually reviewed. If the PR was updated mid-run, valid comments could be silently dropped (or invalid ones admitted). Snapshot the commentable lines during checkout_pr so review-time validation matches the anchor exactly. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#12): route activity monitor's own debug output around the write wrap startProcessOutputMonitor monkey-patches process.stdout.write to mark activity, then called log.debug(...) every 5s to report idle time — which landed right back in its own wrapper, failed isActivityNoise, and called markActivity. with ACTIONS_STEP_DEBUG=true (common on reruns) the idle counter reset every interval and the timeout could never fire, re-creating the #12 zombie-run bug for any debug-enabled run. Fix: capture the original stdout.write and use it directly for the monitor's own diagnostics so they bypass the feedback loop. Added a tight-timeout regression test that asserts the timeout still rejects in debug mode. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#12): noise-filter subprocess.ts monitor logs so outer timer survives debug activity.ts's own monitor output already bypasses the wrap (c35cd3fb), but subprocess.ts's spawn activity timer uses log.debug — which goes straight through process.stdout.write and would still mark activity on every interval when debug logging is enabled. Pattern-filter those '(spawn|process) activity (check|timer|monitor)' lines in both local ([DEBUG] ...) and GH-runner (::debug::...) formats so they don't reset the outer agent-hang timer. Kept scoped to those specific monitor messages — a blanket [DEBUG] filter would silently classify any coincidentally-debug-prefixed agent output as idle, which is a worse failure mode than the one we're fixing. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#11): surface spawn ENOENT-style errors in stderr buffer spawn() resolved with exitCode=1 and an empty stderr when the command itself couldn't start (missing binary, bad permissions). lifecycle.ts then reported 'output: (empty)' to the user, who was explicitly told 'retry if the failure looks flaky' — so every run hit the same wall with no diagnostic trail. Append the '[spawn] <cmd>: <node error>' line to stderrBuffer before resolving so the real cause (ENOENT, EACCES, …) flows through to the hook-warning message. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit(#11,#12): cover executeLifecycleHook typed-timeout routing the typed SpawnTimeoutError + sentinel-code branching introduced in d7ee7fd2 / ea8dd2c4 classifies hung vs failed lifecycle hooks — critical for whether agents retry — but had no unit coverage. add tests for all four branches (no script, exit 0, non-zero exit with retry-if-flaky guidance, timeout with do-NOT-retry guidance, transient spawn failure). Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: re-verify clean tree after prepush hook the pre-prepush check guarantees we enter the hook with a clean tree, but if the hook writes tracked files (formatter, type generator, build artifacts), the push still only sends the pre-hook commit — the hook's edits silently disappear from the upstream branch while the tool reports "successfully pushed". add a post-hook status check so the agent sees the dropped mutations and can commit or discard them before retrying. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: reject push_tags refspec injection via ':' in tag name without tag validation, a tag like "foo:refs/heads/main" concatenated into "refs/tags/${tag}" becomes a valid <src>:<dst> refspec — git pushes the local refs/tags/foo's commit to remote main, bypassing push_branch's default-branch guard. same shape blocks leading '-' (flag injection) and other refspec metacharacters (~ ^ ? * [ \) via an allow-list regex. only reachable in push=enabled today, so this is defense-in-depth, but hardens the tool in case push_tags is ever exposed in restricted mode. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: stop pointing agents at an internal constant they can't change the lifecycle-hook timeout warning told agents to "bump LIFECYCLE_HOOK_TIMEOUT_MS" — but that's a hard-coded constant in the action, not something the agent or repo owner can tune. the agent would plausibly loop hunting for where to change it. redirect to the actual lever they control: ask the repo owner to simplify the hook. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: drop inverted inline-comment ranges locally with precise reason validateInlineComments only checked that both line and start_line anchor inside a hunk, not that start_line <= line. an inverted range (e.g. start=44, line=42) would pass local validation and GitHub would 422 with "invalid line numbers" — opaque to the agent and unfixable without reading docs. reject locally with a reason that names the constraint. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: don't let usage-summary write error mask main's outcome writeGitHubUsageSummaryToFile is called in main's finally block. it can throw on ENOSPC / EACCES / missing parent dir. a throw here propagates past the try's successful return or the catch's error return, hiding the actual run outcome behind an I/O failure on a purely informational file. swallow the write error (debug-logged) — the summary is nice-to-have, not load-bearing. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: don't mislabel agent handler errors as JSON parse failures the onStdout event loop wrapped both JSON.parse and the handler call in one try/catch that logged every caught error as 'non-JSON stdout line'. if a handler threw (e.g. todowrite state shape drift), the error was silently classified as a parse error, making diagnosis impossible. split the try blocks so JSON errors and handler errors get distinct, identifying log lines. * audit: reject leading-dash PR refs before they reach git commands PR head/base refs come from GitHub and are attacker-controlled on fork PRs (the PR author picks headRef freely). they flow straight into `git fetch origin <ref>`, `git checkout -B <ref>`, and config writes. without a leading-dash check, a ref named like '-upload-pack=evil' could be parsed as a flag instead of a refspec. validate both refs at the top of checkoutPrBranch (before any async work) and cover the two attack shapes with unit tests. * audit: cover ActivityTimeout.stop()'s forceReject disarming main.ts's safety-net-timer path depends on ActivityTimeout.stop() nulling out rejectFn so a late safety-net fire after a successful agent run is a no-op. that behavior had no direct coverage — removing the \`rejectFn = null\` in stop() would silently break the happy path (unhandled rejection / spurious failure) without failing any test. add three tests covering: forceReject rejects with the reason, stop() disarms forceReject, and forceReject after timer rejection is an idempotent no-op. * audit: stabilize activity-timeout idleSec against late stdout race * audit: reject 0ms timeout parses to avoid insta-fail from '0m' * audit: surface raw GitHub error on review 422 instead of assuming anchor cause * audit: key commentable-lines cache by PR number to prevent cross-PR drift * audit: enumerate concrete 422 causes and name checkout_pr in review error * audit: stop shipping ralph-loop runtime state in PR history .claude/ralph-loop.local.md and .claude/ralph-loop-prompt.md were accidentally staged in an earlier audit commit. the .local.md suffix is conventional for gitignored runtime state, and the prompt file is per-run harness config — neither should merge to main. ignore the pattern and untrack the existing entries (files remain on disk so the active loop keeps working). * audit: pin commentable-lines cache to checkoutSha, not just PR number a second checkout_pr(N) call advances toolState.checkoutSha at line 305 or 334, then runs fetchAndFormatPrDiff + cache population at line 549. any throw between those two points (rate limit, 5xx, network blip) left the old snapshot keyed to (pullNumber=N) while checkoutSha now points at a different sha. review_pr(N) would reuse the stale snapshot, silently validating comments against the wrong anchor — the original failure this cache was meant to prevent. track commentableLinesCheckoutSha alongside the pull number and require both to match before returning the cache. if either has moved, fall back to listFiles like any other miss. * audit: auto-clear leftover pending review from killed prior runs a workflow timeout or OOM between createReview PENDING and submitReview leaves GitHub holding a pending draft. the next run hits GitHub's one-pending-per-user-per-PR limit and 422s at pending-create, with no way to recover short of a human cleaning up manually. catch 422 at pending-create, list the PR's reviews (GitHub only exposes our own pending to us, so the filter is safe), delete the leftover, and retry once. 404/422 on the cleanup are treated as no-ops (race with another concurrent cleanup or the draft was submitted); any other cleanup error rethrows so the real cause reaches the caller. * audit: extract + unit-test stranded-pending-review cleanup the recovery branch inside createAndSubmitWithFooter had no direct test coverage. a regression in any of its guards (status check, message match, listReviews filter, 404/422 tolerance, non-retryable rethrow) would silently cause either destructive deletes of unrelated reviews or the old failure mode where a stranded pending draft blocks every retry. extract to clearStrandedPendingReview so the cases can be exercised with a mocked octokit, and add tests for each branch — including the load-bearing negative cases (non-422 passthrough, non-pending-review 422 passthrough, no-leftover-found passthrough, non-retryable cleanup error passthrough). no behavior change at the call site. * audit: document concurrent-run race in clearStrandedPendingReview two runs on the same PR using the same GitHub App installation token would both see each other's PENDING draft via listReviews (GitHub exposes PENDING only to the author, and both runs share authorship). the loser's recovery path would delete the winner's active draft, causing the winner's submitReview to 404. no reliable in-request signal distinguishes a genuinely-stranded prior-run draft from an active peer's draft — PENDING reviews have no created_at, and the user field is the same bot in both cases. the correct fix is workflow-level concurrency (a per-PR concurrency key), not a heuristic here. document the limitation so future readers don't try to bolt on a broken heuristic. * audit: report signal-killed subprocesses as failures, not exit code 0 node's close event delivers (code=null, signal=<name>) when a child is killed by signal (OOM killer, segfault, external SIGTERM). the close handler captured only exitCode and coerced null to 0 via `exitCode || 0`, so lifecycle hooks killed by signal were silently reported as successful — lifecycle.ts's `if (result.exitCode !== 0)` check skipped the warning and callers proceeded as if setup/post-checkout/prepush had completed. now capture signal, append "killed by signal <name>" to stderr, and resolve with exitCode=1 when code is null but signal is set. adds a regression test that spawns `kill -KILL \$\$` and asserts a non-zero exit plus the signal-kill marker in stderr. * audit: untrack RUN_ISSUES*.md ralph-loop working docs same pattern called out in 4f14dbf1: these files are per-run harness state and analysis scratch, not merge-to-main deliverables. the TODO literally opens with "Ralph loop instructions:", so it's unambiguously in the same category as .claude/ralph-loop-prompt.md was. files stay on disk so the active loop keeps working. * audit: block refs/... + symbolic-ref bypass of default-branch guard push_branch's restricted-mode guard compared the resolved remoteBranch against defaultBranch with exact-string equality. an agent passing branchName "refs/heads/main" flowed through: rejectIfLeadingDash passed, getPushDestination's fallback preserved the refs/heads/main string as remoteBranch, so "refs/heads/main" !== "main" and the block was skipped, yet git push happily resolved refs/heads/main to the local main commit and pushed to the remote main branch. symbolic refs (HEAD / FETCH_HEAD / ORIG_HEAD / MERGE_HEAD) are the same class of bypass — they resolve to whatever commit they point at, unconstrained by the name-based guard. add rejectSpecialRef to enforce bare branch names at the tool entry, use it in push_branch and delete_branch. checkout_pr only ever assigns pr-<number> as the local branch, so nothing legitimate relied on the refs/... form here. * audit: keep original 422 visible when listReviews fails during pending-review cleanup if listReviews threw (e.g. transient 502, rate limit) during the stranded pending-review recovery path, the listing failure replaced the original 422 "pending review" error when it propagated up through the tool's outer catch. agents then saw a generic server error with no mention of the real blocker and stopped retrying the cleanup. now the listing failure is logged at debug but does not mask the original 422. the caller's retry re-attempts cleanup, which succeeds if the listing failure was transient. * audit: block default-branch deletion even under push: enabled delete_branch required push: enabled, but within that mode the agent could delete the default branch with no local guard. GitHub branch protection usually catches this at the remote, but not every repo has protection configured — and even when it does, relying on remote config for local safety is wrong. pushing to main is reversible (revert, force-push old HEAD); deleting main is not (reflog recovery only, 30-day window). block deletion of the resolved default_branch in DeleteBranchTool regardless of push permission. push: enabled authorizes pushes, not wholesale removal of the repository's primary branch. * audit: attach no-op catch to agentPromise so a late rejection can't crash cleanup agentPromise raced against activityTimeout.promise (and the --timeout timeoutPromise), both of which had .catch(() => {}) handlers. agentPromise did not. if a timeout won the race, agentPromise became stranded and its subsequent rejection was an unhandled rejection — under node 15+'s default unhandled-rejection policy that terminates the process, which would kill main() mid-cleanup and lose the error-reporting and usage-summary work queued in the catch/finally blocks. the race still sees the rejection (the original promise is shared); this catch only prevents node from treating a post-race rejection as unobserved. * audit: close push_branch refspec-injection via ':' / '+' in branchName rejectSpecialRef only forbade leading-dash, `refs/` prefix, and symbolic refs. git push accepts `[+]src[:dst]` refspec syntax, so an agent under push:restricted could smuggle a full refspec through branchName and bypass the downstream exact-string default-branch guard: "evil:refs/heads/main" → push local 'evil' to remote main ":refs/heads/main" → delete remote main ":other" → delete arbitrary branches (outside grant) "+main" → force-push refspec prefix reject ':', '+', '^', '~', '?', '*', '[', '\\', and whitespace — git's own check-ref-format forbids all of them in branch names, so the allow-list cannot false-positive against a legitimate branch. add regression tests. * audit: stop suggesting blocked 'rebase' in push_rejected advice under shell=disabled Why: when push fails with non-fast-forward, the advice told the agent to run 'git rebase origin/...'. In shell=disabled mode the git MCP tool blocks rebase (as an arbitrary-code-execution escape hatch), so the agent's only path forward was to hit the block, read the fallback message, and try merge — one wasted round trip. Now: under shell=disabled we directly suggest 'git merge origin/...', which always works. Under other modes the advice keeps the rebase/merge choice but leads with merge so the example is copy-pastable either way. * audit: harden includeIf cleanup against shell-injection via subsection names setupGit read `includeif.*` keys via `git config --get-regexp`, split on the first space, and fed the result into `execSync(\`git config --unset "${key}"\`)`. git config subsection values preserve arbitrary characters, so a crafted `[includeIf "gitdir:$(touch${IFS}/tmp/pwn)safe"]` entry round-trips through `--get-regexp` with its `$(...)` command substitution intact, survives the split-on-space filter (IFS-bypass leaves the payload space-free), and gets evaluated when interpolated into the shell command. Confirmed reachable as an RCE sink in local repro. Switch to `--get-regexp -z` (null-terminated, no ambiguity on whitespace) and call `$("git", ["config", "--unset-all", key])` which uses spawn-array and never hands the key to a shell. Extract the logic into `removeIncludeIfEntries` and add regression tests covering the injection payload, whitespace-in-subsection keys, benign entries, and the no-op case. * audit: clear SIGKILL escalator on clean SIGTERM exit the overall-timeout path scheduled a 5s SIGKILL follow-up without capturing the timer id. if the child cooperated with SIGTERM and `close` fired promptly, the escalator stayed pending in the event loop for up to 5s — delaying any subsequent clean shutdown (e.g. the main action exiting after an agent timeout) by that long. capture sigkillEscalatorId alongside timeoutId and clear it in both close and error handlers. regression test asserts the active-timer count does not grow past the pre-spawn baseline after a timed-out child exits on SIGTERM. * audit: correct rebase-availability hints to reflect shell=restricted the MCP git tool only blocks rebase when shell=disabled (NOSHELL_BLOCKED_SUBCOMMANDS check in GitTool). under shell=restricted, git({command: "rebase"}) works fine through the tool — NOSHELL_BLOCKED_SUBCOMMANDS doesn't apply. but two agent-facing messages implied rebase is only available with shell=enabled: - AUTH_REQUIRED_REDIRECT["pull"] said "rebase is only available when shell is enabled" - push-rejected integrateStep (non-disabled branch) said "(or 'rebase' if shell is enabled)" under shell=restricted, agents reading these would wrongly think they had to pick merge — pushing them toward merge commits when rebase would have been cleaner. the push-rejected branch is already ternary-gated on shell !== "disabled", so the qualifier there was just redundant noise. * audit: block difftool/mergetool under shell=disabled git difftool -x <cmd> is the short form of --extcmd. the args blocklist only matches --extcmd / --extcmd=*, so -x slipped through and let an agent run arbitrary commands even when shell=disabled. globally blocking -x would false-positive on git cherry-pick -x, which only appends metadata, so block difftool (and mergetool, same shape via mergetool.<name>.cmd) at the subcommand level instead. agents have no legitimate need for either — diffs go through diff/show and merges are resolved by file edits. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> * audit: recover stranded PENDING drafts on no-body createReview too The body path already clears a stranded PENDING draft from a prior crashed run via createAndSubmitWithFooter's own try/catch. The no-body path (approve-with-no-feedback or comments-only) called createReview directly — so a PR whose previous body-path run crashed between createReview(PENDING) and submitReview would permanently 422 any subsequent no-body review with "already has a pending review" until a body-path run happened to clear it. Factored out createReviewWithStrandedRecovery so both paths get the same recovery treatment, and added regression tests covering the no-stranded / stranded-and-retry / non-stranded-422-no-retry cases. * audit: reject timeouts past node's setTimeout ceiling a user-supplied timeout like "999h" parses fine (parseTimeString has no upper cap) but falls off the 2^31-1 ms limit setTimeout clamps to 1ms. the agent run would reject with "timed out after 999h" in a single tick. extract a resolveTimeoutMs helper that centralizes the zero/overflow/ unparseable checks (previously scattered behind inline boolean logic in main.ts) and cover the behavior with unit tests including the boundary value. * fix(#22): replace parameter property in SpawnTimeoutError node --experimental-strip-types rejects readonly/public/private param properties in constructors. tests run via node directly (no tsc), so CI was hitting ERR_UNSUPPORTED_TYPESCRIPT_SYNTAX on every action-agents / action-agnostic job before any test code ran. declare the field and assign in the body instead. * audit: tighten git tool description and delete_branch refspec - `git` tool description previously implied `pull` had a dedicated MCP tool alongside `push_branch`/`git_fetch`. it doesn't — the redirect sends the agent back to the same git tool with `command: "merge"` (or `rebase`). update the description to teach this directly instead of letting agents discover it through the redirect error. - `delete_branch` now passes `refs/heads/${branchName}` to `git push --delete` so a same-named tag can't be silently deleted when both exist on the remote. `rejectSpecialRef` already guarantees the bare-name invariant, so the template construction stays injection-safe. Made-with: Cursor * audit: polish review.ts per anneal findings - drop `as "LEFT" | "RIGHT"` cast in `validateInlineComments` — octokit types `side?: string` at the createReview endpoint, so narrow via `c.side === "LEFT" ? "LEFT" : "RIGHT"`. no cast, no redundant annotation — TS infers the literal union from the ternary. - consolidate `clearStrandedPendingReview` from 3 params to 2 by folding `originalErr` into `params`, per AGENTS.md "max 2 parameters" rule. updates both call sites (`createReviewWithStrandedRecovery`, `createAndSubmitWithFooter`) and all 7 test paths. - upgrade `listReviews`-during-cleanup failure log from `log.debug` to `log.info` so operators not running at debug still see that recovery was attempted before the original 422 bubbles up. message now reads "surfacing original 422" to make the intent unambiguous. Made-with: Cursor * audit: signal partial commit metadata in checkout_pr previously a rev-list/log failure (e.g. shallow fetch where `origin/<base>` isn't reachable) silently returned `commitCount: 0, commitLog: ""` — indistinguishable from "this PR has no commits past base", which could mislead review reasoning about scope. add a `commitLogUnavailable: boolean` field to `CheckoutPrResult`, set when the rev-list/log calls throw. instructions footer now tells the agent to treat the values as "unknown" rather than "no commits" in that case. message phrased to cover the rare case where rev-list succeeds but git log throws (partial, not strictly zero) metadata. Made-with: Cursor * audit: fix parseDiffTocEntries to match production ' · diff-<sha>' TOC suffix the regex required $ right after the line range, but formatFilesWithLineNumbers in checkout.ts appends ` · diff-<sha256>` so agents have the GitHub "Files Changed" anchor precomputed. result: tocEntries was always empty on real PR reviews, breakdown.files was empty, and runDiffCoveragePreflight never fired its one-time "read the diff" nudge. add an optional suffix to the regex and a regression test that uses the exact production TOC shape. Made-with: Cursor * audit(#20): skip empty downgraded-APPROVE reviews before they 422 GitHub rejects `event: "COMMENT"` reviews with no body and no inline comments (HTTP 422 "Unprocessable Entity", verified empirically on repos/pullfrog/preview-546-run-issues-fixes/pulls/1). the runtime `prApproveEnabled` downgrade folds approved=true into event=COMMENT when the repo flag is off, so an agent asking to APPROVE a PR with no other feedback produces exactly that rejected shape — but the existing empty-review skip only fired for !approved cases, so the tool POSTed the doomed COMMENT, octokit returned what looked like a success-with- no-persisted-review shape, and agents reported a phantom reviewId that 404s on any subsequent GET. extract the skip decision into `reviewSkipDecision` and add a second branch for approved + !prApproveEnabled + empty. the function returns null when the review should be submitted, so a real bare APPROVE (approved + prApproveEnabled + empty) still goes through unchanged — GitHub accepts empty APPROVE reviews because the stamp itself is the content. surfaced in the PR #546 preview e2e run 24678139563 (reviewId 4141786854 reported by the agent but absent from every reviews listing). TC13 run 24680349445 re-ran the same scenario with prApproveEnabled=enabled and the review persisted correctly, isolating the cause to the downgrade + empty interaction. * audit(#31): drop misleading rebase mention from pull redirect AUTH_REQUIRED_REDIRECT["pull"] and the git tool's top-level description both said "use git_fetch then this tool with command 'merge' (or 'rebase' unless shell is disabled)". the "(or 'rebase' unless shell is disabled)" qualifier is active misinformation when the agent is already running under shell=disabled: rebase is blocked there by NOSHELL_BLOCKED_SUBCOMMANDS, so the suggestion sends the agent into a second block on the next tool call. 3b83ee97 already fixed this pattern for the push-rejected advice at line 248, but the pull redirect at line 280 and the tool description at line 351 were missed. the right copy isn't a conditional qualifier that agents have to parse against their own shell mode — it's just naming the one alternative that works everywhere (merge). agents under shell=restricted/enabled who want rebase can invoke it directly; the redirect doesn't need to advertise it. verified in preview e2e run 24679728733 (TC8 probe 6) where the agent correctly captured the verbatim redirect message under shell=disabled and explicitly flagged the "(or 'rebase' unless shell is disabled)" clause as confusing — the new test in security.test.ts asserts the message names merge and never rebase in every shell mode. * audit: drop vestigial entry/post references + add preview-546 settings util followup to d79860c6 "refactor: flatten action entrypoints" (Apr 10), which moved action.yml from built `entry`/`post` files to source `entry.ts`/`post.ts` but left three stale references lying around: - .gitignore: `action/run/entry` / `action/dispatch/entry` paths no longer exist anywhere in the build. - .github/workflows/pull-from-action.yml: agent instruction told the upstream sync agent to "Ignore `entry` files (they are built artifacts and .gitignored in this repo)". there are no built entry artifacts anymore — entry.ts is source. - .cursor/settings.json: search.exclude pattern "**/entry" excluded the old built files that no longer exist. none of these were load-bearing on their own, but the same drift had already broken preview e2e end-to-end: the pullfrog/template workflow's three-file copy step (cp .../entry, cp .../post) silently failed with cp: no such file on every preview PR since Apr 10. that template fix went to pullfrog/template@7ec7c8d and the preview-546 mirror at @17ab585, which is what unblocked this PR's full e2e validation. also adds scripts/preview-546-settings.ts, the helper used during the e2e validation to show/set/reset DB-level repo settings on the Neon preview branch (push, shell, prApproveEnabled, hook scripts). scoped to this preview repo ID so it can't accidentally mutate prod. * audit(#11): scope removeIncludeIfEntries to repoDir under inherited GIT_* the function takes `repoDir` as the target, but plain execSync / $(...) inherit GIT_DIR, GIT_WORK_TREE, and GIT_INDEX_FILE from the parent process — and `git config --local` honors GIT_DIR over cwd. when this runs as a child of another git invocation (notably the pre-push hook, but also any future caller embedded inside a git subcommand), the cleanup silently targets the outer repo instead of repoDir. latent today because the real caller is ASKPASS setup, which runs before any git-subcommand ancestor exists, but the function's contract still promised the wrong thing — and the test suite hit exactly this bug when invoked through `git push`. - envScopedToRepo() strips GIT_* before both the get-regexp and unset calls, so cwd wins. - swap the $(...) shell helper for execFileSync on the unset call. $() would merge our scoped env with a "restricted" base that's tuned for hook execution (no tokens) — overkill here and it re-introduces the shell-vs-argv distinction this function was explicitly hardened against in a9aa3b2b. execFileSync with argv is the right tool for a call where the key can contain arbitrary characters. - setup.test.ts also strips GIT_* in its own execSync harness so the suite passes identically under `pnpm vitest run`, `pnpm -r test`, and `git push`'s pre-push hook. --------- Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com> Co-authored-by: Colin McDonnell <colinmcd94@gmail.com> |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
6533ffddae |
intercept arktype's standard-schema jsonSchema.input for Gemini sanitizer
The previous sanitizer proxied `schema.toJsonSchema()`, but fastmcp 3.x uses
`xsschema.toJsonSchema()` which reads `schema["~standard"].jsonSchema.input(...)`
directly when the StandardJSONSchemaV1 extension is present (arktype 2.x).
Our proxy was never invoked, so the sanitizer was a silent no-op.
Proxy the entire `~standard` → `jsonSchema` → `input` chain so the transform
runs regardless of which path xsschema picks. Also add case 1 (add `type:"string"`
to enum-only schemas) — arktype 2.x emits `{enum:["A","B"]}` without a type
field, which is the exact form Gemini rejects with
"only allowed for STRING type".
Verified locally: wrapped schema now emits `{type:"string", enum:[...]}` and
drops `$schema`; validation still works.
|
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
c608051b79 |
sanitize mcp schemas for Gemini; fix gpt-codex-mini alias; add matrix filter
Gemini's generateContent API rejects arktype's `{anyOf:[{enum:[...]}]}` string-enum
encoding, `$schema` metadata, and `anyOf` with sibling fields. Port the old
sanitizer back as an isolated module (action/mcp/geminiSanitizer.ts) and gate it
on `isGeminiRouted(ctx)` so non-gemini routes see the original schema. Wires
`resolvedModel` onto ToolContext so the sanitizer can see the upstream specifier.
Also bumps `openai/gpt-codex-mini` alias from the deprecated `codex-mini-latest`
to `gpt-5.1-codex-mini`, matching the openrouter resolve.
Adds a `filter` workflow_dispatch input + MATRIX_FILTER env that restricts the
models-live matrix to aliases matching a substring, so we can iterate on a
single provider (e.g. `filter=gemini`) without paying to run every model.
|
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
56a5d29598 |
add diff coverage preflight for PR review submissions (#544)
* add one-time diff coverage preflight for PR reviews track diff read coverage from agent tool-use events and run a one-time pre-flight before review submission, with explicit coverage skip reasons for low-value files like lockfiles. Made-with: Cursor * add manual dispatch fallback for preview deploy workflow allow preview repo and preview sync jobs to be run via workflow_dispatch with explicit PR number and branch inputs, so preview provisioning can be retriggered when pull_request events fail to fire. Made-with: Cursor * fix manual preview dispatch PR input wiring use normalized PR number and branch env values for comment creation and script env wiring so workflow_dispatch preview runs can create and update PR-specific preview resources. Made-with: Cursor * remove obsolete snapshots invalidated by checkout instructions change * fix diff coverage read offset handling and add local sanity-check guidance normalize read offset semantics for diff coverage tracking, reuse shared range counting in review preflight, add focused diff coverage unit tests, and document the local play.ts testing workflow in AGENTS.md. Made-with: Cursor * add regenerated mcp test snapshots capture snapshot files generated by the review comment and checkout formatting tests during pre-push validation so the branch remains clean and reproducible. Made-with: Cursor * add diff coverage preflight instrumentation logs log diff coverage initialization in checkout_pr and emit preflight state/breakdown diagnostics in create_pull_request_review to debug missing coverage enforcement in preview e2e runs. Made-with: Cursor * add env override to force local cli execution in action runtime support explicit local-cli execution via PULLFROG_FORCE_LOCAL_CLI so preview workflows can run branch action code instead of the npm fallback package during e2e debugging. Made-with: Cursor * add preview e2e debugging learnings for action runtime validation capture the preview execution-path gotchas and one-time preflight verification pattern in AGENTS.md so future investigations validate the real runtime and avoid npm fallback confusion. Made-with: Cursor * reduce diff coverage log noise while preserving failure visibility downgrade verbose diff coverage lifecycle diagnostics to debug, keep a concise info-level pre-flight failure signal, and document preview runtime debugging learnings in AGENTS.md. Made-with: Cursor * WIP * tune sync.md: ff override + softer overlap verification Made-with: Cursor * chore: bump models snapshot for claude-opus-4-7 Made-with: Cursor * rip out coverage_skips waiver from diff coverage pre-flight Made-with: Cursor --------- Co-authored-by: pullfrog[bot] <226033991+pullfrog[bot]@users.noreply.github.com> |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
18c8d34da6 |
remove task list from review bodies; keep in progress comments only (#542)
review bodies were embedding a task-list snapshot that could capture stale in-progress state due to timing between the agent's final TodoWrite and the review submission API call. progress comments are the authoritative checklist surface — remove the review-body embedding entirely so there is a single source of truth. also adds a `completeInProgress` option to `renderCollapsible` so the progress-comment path can finalize any in-progress items at render time without mutating tracker state. Made-with: Cursor |
||
|
Colin McDonnell
|
2799cce4bf |
homepage redesign + docs cleanup + agent prompting (#540)
* homepage redesign + docs cleanup + agent prompting improvements - rewrote hero section: new tagline, responsive font sizing with clamp(), extracted shared constants for copy management - added feature screenshots (shell isolation, github permissions, mcp tools, agent browser) and ensured consistent image sizing - reworked feature section mobile layout: caption-style descriptions, bigger h3s, image padding - made CTA buttons visible on all breakpoints (stacked on mobile, row on md+) - reorganized docs/tools.mdx into single table with category dividers, simplified tool descriptions - added markdown image syntax instruction to agent system prompt - fixed InfoPopover overflow on small screens - misc: InlineCode proportional sizing, OnboardingCard updates, shell/security doc improvements Made-with: Cursor * update pnpm-lock.yaml for agent-browser 0.25.4 Made-with: Cursor |